3 ms·
> Handing out free money will most likely just cause inflation and defeat itself. The inflation will make the amount paid out in basic income insufficient to li
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> Handing out free money will most likely just cause inflation and defeat itself. The inflation will make the amount paid out in basic income insufficient to live on.
I may start calling this the "it is impossible to reduce inequality" fallacy.
If you gave everyone money, would things cost more? Maybe some things. Not everything, and not by 100.0% of the amount of money provided.
Because some of the money gets saved or used to pay down debts, not spent, and only makes people more secure rather than affecting prices. And not everything has the same price elasticity of supply. There are no practical resource limits on how many electronic devices or kitchen tables or wind turbines we can build. If more people can afford them, the price doesn't have to go up because the supply can go up at approximately the same price.
And the money comes from somewhere, unless you're outright printing it, so consumption goes down to some degree there when it goes up somewhere else.
The fact that you get the same amount of inflation you get by anything else that causes the poor to have more money is not a real problem. Getting $1000 and then paying $100 more for stuff is $900 better than the status quo.
Especially since the current problem is not enough inflation -- the Fed keeps wanting to raise interest rates and can't because as low as they are there is still no almost inflation. They keep missing their inflation target on the low side:
https://www.marketwatch.com/story/feds-bullard-says-interest-rate-policy-stance-is-now-a-little-bit-restrictive-2019-02-07 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/feds-bullard-says-interest...
Meanwhile everyone is saturated with debt, which inflation helps erode, so having a little more would be better.
- mindslight 8y agoSaying that inflation is low is referring to a broken metric. Inflation in housing, healthcare, and education have significantly contributed to the current problem in the US. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19106964 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19106964 I would say the root problem is all that debt, specifically the ongoing costs of servicing the debt. Staying alive does intrinsically require ongoing expenses for food, energy, shelter upkeep, personal grooming, etc. But the cost of these is dwarfed by the amount spent on rent (aka debt) for the space on which the shelter resides. Basic income is really just a natural progression of the last several decades's policy of overwhelming monetary inflation. If the BI mostly goes towards just servicing debt then it's only increasing the speed of that debt treadmill and making people's financial position ever-more precarious - they then depend on both continuing to hold down their job, and conforming to whatever conditions will be placed on the BI. The one sensible thing BI would do is allow people to have income in areas with low economic activity, which is great for those willing to "retire" to such areas. It's just not going to alleviate the pain of the average person having to "make rent" as everyone seemingly envisions.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThere is a very specific reason housing, healthcare and education costs are so high -- the government keeps subsidizing them in particular. Mortgage interest tax deduction, exclusion from capital gains tax, employer health insurance deduction, ACA subsidies, federal student loan interest deduction and subsidies, etc. The problem with all of this is that it doesn't cause general inflation, it only raises the cost of those specific things. Which means in particular that it doesn't raise general wages, so the cost of those things increase relative to wages. On top of that most of those subsidies are to loan interest rather than principal, so the incentive is to take out a huge loan, which multiplies the effect on overall price. They really are very poorly designed policies. Unless you're a bank or an insurance company or an existing landlord. A UBI is the opposite of that. It doesn't require you to do anything in particular, so it doesn't raise the price of anything in particular relative to everything else. It also helps you out of the megopolis treadmill. The job in Pittsburgh pays $50,000, but the job in SF pays $150,000, so you take that one. Then you learn it costs $100,000 more to live in SF at the same quality of life, so you're really only just breaking even. Add $12,000 worth of UBI and it becomes more advantageous to live in the median city than the huge megopolis, because the extra $12,000 goes further there and unlike the salary it's the same amount in both places. So more people do, and prices fall everywhere, because that's also more efficient. You increase economies of scale by increasing population in the smaller cities while reducing resource contention in the huge cities where economies of scale are already maxed out. And likewise if you replace student loans and healthcare subsidies with the UBI, the cost of education and healthcare comes down, because then people don't lose any part of the subsidy if they choose a less expensive school or a higher deductible insurance policy, they just get to use it for something else. Like for patronizing service workers, which increases their wages relative to housing/healthcare/education.
- mindslight 8y agoI agree with much of what you said including that costs are high due to government subsidies - I just think that the primary subsidy is keeping general interest rates low. That mortgage interest tax deduction really just further reduces the the effective interest rate for home loans. The primary subsidy isn't even acknowledged as an explicit policy, but obscured by describing it as a mechanical application of a purported economic consensus. I guess my point of disagreement is that since the low interest subsidy is basically turning any mildly dense area into a rent treadmill, then why isn't the goal to directly address that as the problem? The increasing financialization of most people's lives (pet insurance!!) seems like a much more pressing issue than trying to indirectly prop up rural economy.