6 ms·
I always think of Star Trek. It isn't really explored in depth but there isn't money and people don't have to work, transporter rationing is alluded to though.
by benj111 8y ago
I always think of Star Trek. It isn't really explored in depth but there isn't money and people don't have to work, transporter rationing is alluded to though.
I guess in a world where everything can be made in a replicator, 'employment' becomes untenable. You still need some way of rationing scarce resources, and allowing people to 'vote' for what they want more of though.
- Retric 8y agoScarcity is beyond just stuff. Land for example is a finite resource.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoIt is and it isn't. Land in Manhattan is scarce. Land in the non-coastal western US or most of Canada or Australia is theoretically scarce too, but not so much in practice.
- michaelchisari 8y agoIf humanity lived at the density of Paris (21,438/km^2), we could all live in an area half the size of Texas (695,663 km^2). So if we're talking about material post-scarcity, land is more than plentiful.
- nostrademons 8y agoIf humanity lived at the density of Wyoming (5.97/mi^2), we would have to get rid of 50% of the U.S. population or 98% of the world population, because only 147M people could fit on the habitable land on earth. So yes, it is and it isn't. The question is how many people want to live in Wyoming-level densities vs. Paris-level densities, given the elimination of any cost constraints.
- Wowfunhappy 8y ago> The question is how many people want to live in Wyoming-level densities vs. Paris-level densities. Do they get a choice? I want to live in Disneyland, but there's sadly a distinct lack of real estate available.
- nostrademons 8y agoThat's sort of the definition of a post-scarcity world. If people want stuff but can't have it because there's not enough to go around, that's pretty much the definition of scarcity.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoThe idea of a "post-scarcity" world is silly. Some resources will always be limited. Land, diamonds, prestige, etc. What matters is, how scarce are the necessities of a moderately-comfortable life? I would posit that people who live in cities do just fine. If some people want more space, well, you can still work for it. Not all jobs are going to disappear.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Land in the non-coastal western US or most of Canada or Australia is theoretically scarce too, but not so much in practice. If the acquisition cost is >0, it is scarce in practice as well as theory.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago"In theory there is no difference between theory and practice but in practice there is." Land in these places can be something like $500/acre. That's not zero, but compared to the land prices people are more familiar with, it's as close as makes no difference in practice.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Land in these places can be something like $500/acre. That's not zero ...and thus economically scarce... > but compared to the land prices people are more familiar with, it's as close as makes no difference in practice. It's very cheap. But very cheap things are still scarce. Something that isn't scarce has no price and everyone (even the poorest of the poor) who wants any quantity of it will have as much as they want without sacrificing anything. Land in the places you describe is cheap. The price may even seem negligible to people in the upper middle class in the developed world. It's very much still scarce. The difference between scarce and not scarce is not a matter of price, it's a fundamental difference of kind.
- a-priori 8y agoHorizontally maybe, but not vertically.
- savanaly 8y agoIf we are efficient enough in our use of land, the demand relative to the supply will shrink enough that it's no longer scarce. I suppose lots of people enjoy owning their own land-- large tracts of it in fact, and not sharing it with anyone. That's a little tougher to conceptualize as post-scarcity as there's a limit to making land enjoyment more efficient with advanced technology. But in a world where other resources are less scarce perhaps we can think about colonizing other planets and terraforming as ways to increase supply.
- kardos 8y agoNot really. Even if we triple land use efficiency, population growth will increase the demand to compensate
- antris 8y agoPopulation growth has been steadily slowing down since 1960s.
- kardos 8y agoBroadly speaking, that is because we're approaching something like a carrying capacity, estimated to be somewhere around 10B. If we increase land use efficiency dramatically, that effectively raises the carrying capacity and population growth can continue much longer
- antris 8y agoThe population growth decline is not tied to the carrying capacity but to the development of the economy. Countries that are further economically developed have lower birth rates and vice versa. For example Finland is mostly a country of deserted forest, yet it has a very slow growth rate. The country could carry a population of 50 million easily, but is hardly growing anymore at 5 million.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoNot at current fertility rates. If the current trend continues we're in for a world-wide population decline.
- biztos 8y agoSo post-scarcity we should all join the Space Force and subject ourselves to the Captain's whims? I'll take scarcity, thank you.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]