4 ms·
In short, building more housing for "rich" people frees up more housing for everyone. This is not true. Building too much housing for rich people simply resul
by gamblor956 8y ago
In short, building more housing for "rich" people frees up more housing for everyone.
This is not true. Building too much housing for rich people simply results in a lot of empty housing. See for example, Manhattan or Vancouver, which have hundreds of empty condos that could be occupied by locals but are instead owned by wealthy foreigners who leave the units vacant.
- JAlexoid 8y agoSo... Wealthy foreigners buy in Brooklyn or Williamsburg... Raising the prices in places there. I'd say - just kill all "rent stabilization" in sub-100th st on Manhattan and move all social housing out. Sell the land to the millionaires and put up sales taxes for non-residents elsewhere in NYC to 50%. Let the millionaires fight it out in Manhattan... they already do that today!
- gamblor956 8y agoRaising the sales tax to 50% for non-residents wouldn't accomplish anything since the problem is that the non-residents aren't residing in NY. Sales tax doesn't apply to real property sales, so presumably you meant to suggest a real estate tax that would only apply to non-residents...which could be trivially avoided by hiring a token caretaker to pay utility bills, turn on the lights, etc., to make the property look occupied (which is what Chinese investors have been doing since Vancouver introduced the vacant property tax.)
- landryraccoon 8y agoWealthy foreigners is orthogonal. There are policy solutions that can target it directly. For example, property taxes on units left vacant should be higher.
- _whiteCaps_ 8y agoBC is trying this: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/opt-out-or-else-you-ll-pay-provincial-speculation-tax-by-default-1.4982212 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/opt-out-or-e...
- ryandrake 8y agoEven if the housing is not luxury condos for the rich, as long as real estate is appreciating, the economic incentive is for rich people to buy them and leave them empty, like a bar of gold sitting in a vault. This is happening a little bit in my working class neighborhood. House goes on the market. It’s listed as sold, family moves out, nobody moves in. Likely some millionaire’s 8th empty investment house.
- djmobley 8y agoBy and large, rich people invest in real estate because, in most urban areas, it is an increasingly scarce, and therefore increasingly valuable asset. It's a good investment. The solution is not to give up and stop building real estate, making it an even more attractive investment. The solution is to build so much real estate that we tip the balance, and make real estate unattractive to speculative investors.
- gamblor956 8y agoThe solution is to build so much real estate that we tip the balance, and make real estate unattractive to speculative investors. The market can stay irrational for a long time. China has spent hundreds of billions on empty housing in planned cities the past few years, and they're still going due to speculative investor demand. Let's face it: the evidence shows that the easiest and most cost effective way to deal with this problem is market-informed regulation.