2 ms·
> Why? Not all of evolution is adaptive. Because a) humans have been wildly successful, and b) the fact that our brain is inordinately expensive, so if a new c
by naasking 8y ago
> Why? Not all of evolution is adaptive.
Because a) humans have been wildly successful, and b) the fact that our brain is inordinately expensive, so if a new class of non-conscious humans that were equally adept as conscious ones ever arose, they would easily outcompete us for resources. Given our numbers, presumably such non-conscious people would already exist. If so, where are they?
> It's also possible that consciousness is something more fundamental that strongly emerges when the right sort of physical activity takes place.
Depends what you mean by "more fundamental". All of our behaviour emerges when the right sort of physical activity takes place. Our entire brain is filled with "rich information processing", so that's an insufficient qualifier.
- goatlover 8y ago> Because a) humans have been wildly successful, and b) the fact that our brain is inordinately expensive, so if a new class of non-conscious humans that were equally adept as conscious ones ever arose, they would easily outcompete us for resources. Assuming that there's an extra cost to consciousness. The problem here is that nobody knows how to fit consciousness into the physical picture. There's clearly a correlation, but we don't know how and what that entails.
- naasking 8y agoThere's definitely a cost to consciousness if it's not some innate property of matter ala panpsychism. There's no free lunch. But at least we can agree that we don't know how it fits, but I think the attention schema theory is a great start on a mechanistic account: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00500/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.0050...
- salthound 8y agoIn humans, the optic nerve routes in front of the retina, creating a 14 degrees wide blind spot in our vision. The nerves could equally well route behind the retina, eliminating the blind spots essentially for free. Given how important vision was in our evolutionary past, and given our numbers, presumably people without blind spots would already exist. If so, where are they? "Evolutionary Occam's razor" arguments do not work, because evolution gets stuck in local optima all the time. There might simply be no short evolutionary route between "conscious" humans and equally fit "non-conscious" ones (whatever that means).
- naasking 8y ago> The nerves could equally well route behind the retina, eliminating the blind spots essentially for free. Given how important vision was in our evolutionary past, and given our numbers, presumably people without blind spots would already exist. If so, where are they? They might exist, but the adaptive advantage of eliminating the blindspot is minimal: the blindspot life particularly life threatening. The magnitude of the advantage is what matters here. Like I said, the brain is one of our most expensive organs in terms of energy. > There might simply be no short evolutionary route between "conscious" humans and equally fit "non-conscious" ones (whatever that means). But that's essentially the point I was making: if eliminating consciousness requires many changes to reproduce its behaviour, then clearly it serves a functional purpose that is not trivially dismissed.
- naasking 8y ago> the blindspot life particularly life threatening. Err, I meant the blindspot is not particularly life threatening.