6 ms·
So hundreds of people who could live in those condos will instead have to commute from further out, or pay more for an alternative apartment, or not be able to
by lmm 8y ago
So hundreds of people who could live in those condos will instead have to commute from further out, or pay more for an alternative apartment, or not be able to pursue their New York dreams at all. Why is that something we romanticise?
- puzzle 8y agoFrom the article, given the area it's in, it doesn't sound like it would necessarily host low-income or middle-class families. Call me cynical, but I see those condos being someone's third or fourth home and being empty half the time.
- briandear 8y ago> it doesn't sound like it would necessarily host low-income or middle-class families So what? An increase in housing supply results in lower prices for everyone. If the "rich" are buying a condo in location A, that means they're likely not buying that condo in location B. That means the price has to be lowered since now A and B are competing. If A and B are competing for rich people, that means less "rich people" demand in location C. In a place like Sunnyvale, houses are exceeding $1.5 million for essentially starter homes. If there were a larger supply in, say, Palo Alto, that would mean less demand in Sunnyvale, which means more people could afford to live there even if they couldn't afford Palo Alto. There just aren't enough places for sale in the area, so even if someone wanted to buy at the higher-end, the supply is constricted which means they have a lot of money to spend elsewhere. Increasing high-end housing in Palo Alto necessarily decreases demand in lower cost neighborhoods in the area. In short, building more housing for "rich" people frees up more housing for everyone.
- lm28469 8y ago> So what? An increase in housing supply results in lower prices for everyone. If the "rich" are buying a condo in location A, that means they're likely not buying that condo in location B. That means the price has to be lowered since now A and B are competing. If A and B are competing for rich people, that means less "rich people" demand in location C. This kind of intuition rarely work in real life though. People migration flows and the housing market isn't a A+B=C type of problem.
- gamblor956 8y agoIn short, building more housing for "rich" people frees up more housing for everyone. This is not true. Building too much housing for rich people simply results in a lot of empty housing. See for example, Manhattan or Vancouver, which have hundreds of empty condos that could be occupied by locals but are instead owned by wealthy foreigners who leave the units vacant.
- JAlexoid 8y agoSo... Wealthy foreigners buy in Brooklyn or Williamsburg... Raising the prices in places there. I'd say - just kill all "rent stabilization" in sub-100th st on Manhattan and move all social housing out. Sell the land to the millionaires and put up sales taxes for non-residents elsewhere in NYC to 50%. Let the millionaires fight it out in Manhattan... they already do that today!
- gamblor956 8y agoRaising the sales tax to 50% for non-residents wouldn't accomplish anything since the problem is that the non-residents aren't residing in NY. Sales tax doesn't apply to real property sales, so presumably you meant to suggest a real estate tax that would only apply to non-residents...which could be trivially avoided by hiring a token caretaker to pay utility bills, turn on the lights, etc., to make the property look occupied (which is what Chinese investors have been doing since Vancouver introduced the vacant property tax.)
- landryraccoon 8y agoWealthy foreigners is orthogonal. There are policy solutions that can target it directly. For example, property taxes on units left vacant should be higher.
- _whiteCaps_ 8y agoBC is trying this: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/opt-out-or-else-you-ll-pay-provincial-speculation-tax-by-default-1.4982212 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/opt-out-or-e...
- puzzle 8y agoHow many (mostly) empty places do you know of in Sunnyvale or Palo Alto? I know of many in NYC, e.g. this dentist from out of state who has an apartment in the UES. The markets are different at the middle and high end. (By the way, I do remember the days when Bay Area housing was quite cheaper than NYC...) This kind of "trickle down" in NYC real estate exists, sure, but it doesn't spread very far. You could make more difference for "regular" folks if e.g. you added mixed-income restrictions on the new property, but by default the market doesn't work that way.
- taffer 8y ago> You could make more difference for "regular" folks if e.g. you added mixed-income restrictions on the new property, but by default the market doesn't work that way. Research [1] shows that these types of restrictions lead to the exact opposite: A shrinking supply of affordable housing and rapidly rising property prices. [1] http://smartgrowth.umd.edu/assets/documents/research/knaapbentolowe_2008.pdf http://smartgrowth.umd.edu/assets/documents/research/knaapbe...
- JAlexoid 8y ago+100000 - New York and Federal government fails to address the massive difference of income value between places. An annual income of 50k in Houston is equal to 100k in NYC... That also leads to lower middle class being subsidized heavily by the rest of the middle class. Which leads me to the ultimately retarded 80/20 rule in "affordable" housing in NYC. Who pays the difference between that $1200 600ft2 apartment occupied by a single New York "artist" and the market price of the rent for the same apartment occupied by a working family of two? That middle class in NYC needs 2x more money to have as much as middle class in Houston...
- Spooky23 8y agoExcept you need to live in Texas. You’d have to pay me 10x to live there.
- deadmetheny 8y agoWhy are other people entitled to live there?
- cfmcdonald 8y agoThis is not a fair argument. Why should you assume that condos is the 'correct' thing for this land and factory is the 'wrong' thing? Isn't that for the market to decide? What if I told you someone was offering to buy the property to replace it with an orphanage, would you say this woman is denying poor, helpless children a place of refuge? Isn't this woman exercising her property rights in a perfectly fair way within the market economy that we have, in exactly the same way that so many developers have exercised their rights to tear down X and replace it with Y, where many people might have preferred to keep X?
- djmobley 8y agoShe is an irrational actor who is preventing a more efficient allocation of a scarce resource. If she weren’t so notably irrational, the New York Times wouldn’t be writing an article on her.
- lm28469 8y ago> She is an irrational actor Human beings are deeply irrational, not everything has to be tweaked for maximum output / productivity / efficiency / optimisation.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoThere is a nationwide housing crisis in city centers, so yes, this could stand some tweaking for more efficiency.
- fixvzbdjzis 8y agoWell build over Central Park or whatever other irrational allocation of land you cherish.
- AngryData 8y agoSounds like an inevitable problem of too high of a population density. We have plenty of land elsewhere, maybe we should be looking at fixing our transportation systems and incentivizing work outside of these areas so that we don't have to all pile together like cords of wood.
- max76 8y agoI like when someone's primary motivation is not personal greed. It is a rare and beautiful thing.
- eanzenberg 8y agoIt is greed though, but of a different kind. Self-needs before the needs of the rest.
- shadowbannedtoo 8y ago"The needs of the rest?" You mean the needs of the wealthy whom can afford luxury condos? The wealthy are not the rest. They are the few. (The reason why NY, and SF always yack about condos is because the wealthy don't want to build apartments. Heavens forbid some sad sack gets rent-control?)
- ProAm 8y agoWhy should someone forfeit their wishes only so you can pursue yours? You're saying one persons greed is more valuable than the other.
- geofft 8y agoOf course some forms of greed are more valuable than others. If one person's greed is "I want to make ten million dollars so I can create some jobs" and another's is "I want to make ten million dollars so I can put it in the bank and feel accomplished," all other things being equal, just about everyone from Reagan to Bernie to Jesus is going to say that the first person's greed is more worthwhile.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AngryData 8y agoI agree with your ideals, but when our financial systems are favored towards the second person's preferences that ideology doesn't mean anything in practice because it is not systemic. Trying to handpick cases like this to decide who is more worthy or not isn't fair when that same scrutiny isn't passed upon nearly anybody else. Im not sure we would even have think about this case if we taxed capital gains higher than income. If people want to sit and do nothing with something with our current version of capitalism, they should be allowed to, provided they are willing to pay for it with a bit higher tax rate. I don't think doing otherwise will lead to anything besides present more avenues for corruption within our current economic model. Now if all factory property was put under scrutiny of public ideal and no longer privately owned, maybe something could be figured out, but without knowing what economic model to assume in that place there are a near endless number of potential solutions.
- dspillett 8y agoSo she should be forced to abandon a working factory for someone else so use the space? Is your house bigger than you absolutely need? Do you have a garden? Would you like to be forced to give it up so multiple smaller living units could be built? It is hers, she can choose to maintain it for its current use if she wishes, unless it is causing harm. There is a grey area here with derelict sites, as that is a waste of space and often they can be dangerous, but that does not appear to be the case here.
- lmm 8y agoFWIW it sounds like it's not even a working factory any more. A rich person has every right to burn a pile of money or spend it on some extravagant luxury, but we still consider it distasteful when they do. Particularly when that pile of money is unearned, which seems to be the case here - it's only an accident of birth, and an accident of factory location, that means the factory is now on such valuable land. In my ideal world there would be a land value tax so that people paid a fair rate to the rest of society for the land they were taking up, rather than the lottery of buying land once and owning it forever.
- sundbry 8y agoThat's what property taxes are. Are you daft?
- taffer 8y agoProperty taxes and land value taxes are absolutely not the same. Unlike property taxes, land value taxes do not cause any deadweight costs, as the supply of land is fixed and can even increase allocational efficiency.
- Junk_Collector 8y agoProperty taxes require people to pay a portion of the assessed value of property they hold. Land value tax implies the existence of a third party with no aligned incentive that punishes you for not using your property in the manner they deem most suitable.
- forgotAgain 8y agoI've read that the sense of smell is the strongest sense for bringing back memories. When I read the title of the OP I could smell what the inside of the building was like from having spent many hours in similar environments. Why preserve it? Because its better for our spirit to preserve some memories of the past rather than tearing them down for another handful of forgettable multi-million dollar condos.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoThe cheapest unit next door at 40 Bond Street is ~$3M. This building would only be housing elites who can live elsewhere.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoIncreased inventory takes pressure off everyone. Also, she could perhaps stipulate restrictions on the new owner, though would probably take a monetary hit to do so.
- Spooky23 8y agoIt’s called private property. I have an extra bedroom. It would be maximally efficient to rent the room, but I prefer to put my luggage in there.
- njharman 8y agoBecause it's romantic, an optimistic fantasy, to believe freedom of choice and personal responsibility will become valued over "I am special" and "world should work around me" attitudes. It's not owner's job to fulfill other people's dreams or to mitigate other people's poor lives.