3 ms·
So, if the government denies a treatment that could save my life due to some cost / benefit calculation, I can't get access to that treatment, even if I manged
by zdragnar 8y ago
So, if the government denies a treatment that could save my life due to some cost / benefit calculation, I can't get access to that treatment, even if I manged to raise funds for it on my own?
Come to think of it, if this passes, I'm going to lose access to a medication that I'm taking right now. Insurance denied coverage for it because they want me to try a half dozen others first, even though all of them have significantly worse side effects. I'm only able to get what I'm currently taking because the manufacturer covers the cost through their charitable foundation for anyone who can't get insurance / insurance approval.
If "medicare" for all banishes not only private coverage but all private care, and that extends to coverage for drugs, I'm f*cked. Death Panels indeed :(
- creaghpatr 8y agoYour government-enforced death will enable millions more to have basic coverage so don't feel bad.
- zdragnar 8y agoGranted, it's a condition that practically guarantees that my lifespan will be shorter than if I didn't have it. On the other hand: 1) We already have medicaid programs for the poor 2) We already have medicare programs for those not in the workforce (age, disability, etc) 3) We already offer subsidies for those who cannot afford traditional plans but don't qualify for a medicaid or medicare program 4) Medicare still costs money. It's a public insurance plan, not "free for all". So no, it won't give millions basic coverage that they couldn't already get. I'd prefer my death to be a bit more meaningful than fulfilling getting some politician political points, because that's pretty much all it would do under such a system. The above points don't add up to a perfect society; maybe we could work on improving those instead. Edit: For those not in the know, elderly pay for medicare out of their Social Security income. Anyone who reads "Medicare for all" as "Free healthcare for all" is either misinterpreting what's being offered, or what's being offered is a lie.
- alasdair_ 8y agoThere will still be private providers. Edit: read my response below before downvoting. There will be non-participating private providers.
- leereeves 8y ago> The bill ... will not allow participating institutions and providers to offer private care for covered services
- crooked-v 8y agoNot all institutions and providers would choose to participate.
- alasdair_ 8y agoRight. So there will be private providers that do not participate. The same thing happens in the UK - you could visit a private hospital if you want to (and many people do) but if the institution is a public-funded one then they don’t get to offer different levels of care for different people. You can absolutely have a private, non-participating hospital or practice under the proposed plan.
- DanBC 8y ago> but if the institution is a public-funded one then they don’t get to offer different levels of care for different people. This is incorrect. Many NHS hospitals have private wings, and since Lansley there's no laws or regulations to stop hospital trusts providing basic service for all and better service for paying customers.
- zdragnar 8y agoMy situation is one of medication payment, not in-patient treatments You can bet that one of the worlds' largest drug manufacturers, and the pharmacies that provide their medications, aren't going to opt out of participating. If the bill truly makes participation all-or-nothing, I'm SOL. (US health insurance covers both treatment and medication; I'm assuming that the participation rule in this bill applies to both).