3 ms·
I'm not really clear what Chalmers means by 'rich information processing' though, and yes I have read some of his stuff and IMHO he doesn't seem to either. He's
by simonh 8y ago
I'm not really clear what Chalmers means by 'rich information processing' though, and yes I have read some of his stuff and IMHO he doesn't seem to either. He's super smart and well worth reading, but I happen to disagree on this.
>It's also possible that consciousness is something more fundamental that strongly emerges when the right sort of physical activity takes place
Since brains seem to be physical and are conscious, yes they seem to be performing the right sort of activity but that's pretty much tautological. At least the idea that self image and self awareness are key is a concrete theory that we have a chance of testing.
Maybe it's a sort of self-modeling feedback loop. Our brains model our physical bodies, mental state and the mental state of others. At some point, this modeling becomes sophisticated enough to become recursive. The model includes cruder approximations of those models, etc like being between two mirrors facing each other. The symbolic representations expand beyond our ability to perceive them. We become aware of our awareness. Bang! You're conscious.
- goatlover 8y ago> Maybe it's a sort of self-modeling feedback loop. Our brains model our physical bodies, mental state and the mental state of others. At some point, this modeling becomes sophisticated enough to become recursive. The model includes cruder approximations of those models, etc like being between two mirrors facing each other. The symbolic representations expand beyond our ability to perceive them. We become aware of our awareness. Bang! You're conscious. I don't see how sensations like color, sound, pain arise from a feedback loop. And those sensations are what make up our conscious experiences. It's an interesting way of approaching the problem, but it honestly sounds like a bunch of functional words strung together to magically produce qualia, because mirrors are a neat analogy.
- simonh 8y ago>I don't see how sensations like color, sound, pain arise from a feedback loop. And those sensations are what make up our conscious experiences. Neither do I, but you have to start somewhere and 'rich information processing' is so broad it's pretty much nowhere. I suspect qualia are a red herring. I'm not always aware of qualia while I am thinking. When I pay attention to things, sure, I experience them very vividly, but I don't think that's a defining thing about consciousness. It's an open question for me though and not something to just dismiss.
- benji-york 8y agoThis discussion reminds me of the first chapters of Greg Egan's Diaspora. I suspect Amazon's free sample would cover the pertinent parts.