6 ms·
The only thing strange about it is how much easier it is to learn about these conspiracies now that we have the Internet. People are acting all shocked like th
by nerdponx 8y ago
The only thing strange about it is how much easier it is to learn about these conspiracies now that we have the Internet.
People are acting all shocked like this is a new state of affairs. It's not. We are just far more empowered now to actually learn about these things.
- hedvig 8y agoEmpowered to learn maybe, but no change in power to act it feels like.
- everdev 8y agoNot all Presidents or foreign powers are obsessed with finding and collecting dirt on their enemies with the intent to harm or influence them. Wether you call it gaining influence or blackmail, it's usually the technique of authoritarians or the corrupt and not a path we want to advocate or even tolerate.
- malvosenior 8y ago> Not all Presidents or foreign powers are obsessed with finding and collecting dirt on their enemies with the intent to harm or influence them. Yes, all presidents and foreign powers do this. Although Bezos doesn't present any proof that it's actually happening here, just speculation.
- matthewdgreen 8y agoLet's be clear here: I'm the last person to defend the NSA, but there are huge differences in the restrictions placed on official US spying agencies and foreign ones. If a sitting President used his office to demand that the NSA spy on a US citizen for political reasons, it would be a huge scandal. When foreign governments like the Russians or Saudis do it, it's unprosecutable and "deniable", even if the President hints that he wants it to happen and expresses happiness that it has. That's the era we're living in, and it's dangerous as hell.
- malvosenior 8y agoSadly the era we're living in is that which blames Trump for every thing that goes wrong with no evidence whatsoever and many, many people cheer. That is dangerous as hell. I'm happy to be proven wrong but to also be clear: there is zero evidence that Trump had anything to do with this.
- abrahamepton 8y agoZero evidence, sure. But a pattern of behavior that is deeply, deeply troubling and suspicious. As others have pointed out, he tweet-taunted Bezos a few weeks ago in a way that seems rather connected to this recent revelation. Joe Scarborough and Mike Brzezinski wrote an op-ed (in the Post!!) about having been threatened with blackmail by AMI, seemingly in direct connection to the White House's desires. Ronan Farrow came forward yesterday to say that AMI tried something similar with him. Sure, Trump may have nothing to do with it. But you and I aren't courts of law; we're people, and we're allowed to look at the evidence and come to our own conclusions. If your conclusion is that this is an "era ... which blames Trump for every thing that goes wrong with no evidence whatsoever" then you're just doing a bad job of evaluating evidence.
- wahern 8y agoA pattern of behavior is evidence. All evidence is circumstantial. That realization is actually foundational to our system of criminal Due Process. It's why nearly every piece of evidence entered into trial, even simple documents and scientific analyses, requires a witness to vouchsafe. Facts cannot be divorced from their human origin, and any fact can be challenged by challenging the credibility of its origin. All facts are messy things, and while some are messier than others there's no avoiding careful consideration in light of the available context. It follows that the distinction between fact and conjecture is one of opinion.
- everdev 8y ago> Sadly the era we're living in is that which blames Trump for every thing that goes wrong with no evidence whatsoever Before a crime is proven, there's usually speculation. Just like people suspected Nixon of being involved in Watergate before there was actual proof. The truth can come slowly. I agree that we need to follow due process, but it's just as dangerous to categorize any suspicion of criminal activity as "blaming Trump for everything". You're just on the opposite end of the spectrum as people who thinks he's guilty before we have proof. Evidence takes time, especially with plea bargains where there's incentive to hold out until the evidence against you is overwhelming. It's best to be somewhere in the middle where you're equally skeptical and open to whatever news and evidence comes out.
- squozzer 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J._Edgar_Hoover https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J._Edgar_Hoover
- njarboe 8y agoHead of the FBI and its predecessor from 1924 till 1972. So, for the US, we had a department "obsessed with finding and collecting dirt on their enemies with the intent to harm or influence them" for at least that time period.
- wahern 8y agoRight, and Hoover's techniques were those of an authoritarian which few in Washington wished to support or tolerate. The problem was that Hoover's enemies included those very same Washington leaders, whom he'd quietly threaten. By contrast, we've arrived at a point where those very same techniques, practiced openly and brazenly, are considered legitimate in the eyes of a significant plurality of both Washington leaders and the national electorate. Corruption has always existed, but unless it's normalized you at least have a fighting change of containing it. When its normalized it will consume the whole system. Pervasive cynicism is sufficient to normalize it, and that's often how it metastasizes.
- abrahamepton 8y agoNo, that's not "the only thing strange" about this. Perhaps you're unfamiliar with American history, but this is wildly without any remote precedent. Not to say that previous Presidents haven't done bad things, abused laws, etc, (shit, even launched disinfo campaigns, used the press to attack enemies, etc) but this is just gobsmackingly different from what has come before. Obviously caveat "if this is true" blah blah blah because my Lord who knows what's true anymore. But knock off the jaded pseudo-educated bs; this is radically fucking strange and a departure from history up until this point.
- creaghpatr 8y agoYou need to read about the measures great past Presidents like Abraham Lincoln, amongst others, took. It's gonna be an eye-opening experience for you if your comment is in good faith.
- abrahamepton 8y agoUh huh. Please provide even a single example. Keep in mind the standard you've gotta match or beat: a President elected in significant part by collaborating with a foreign adversary to undermine our elections, and in significant part by using a media outlet to cover up his scandals. Said President is accused of using said media outlet to blackmail his enemies, going back at least years if not decades. One of those enemies, the richest man on Earth, also owns one of the most influential news organizations in the country. While we don't know all the details, it appears that said President and said media company also have extensive relations with yet another country that just murdered a US-resident journalist in their own consulate in a NATO country. Said President and his family worked with this other country on, among other things, instituting a blockade of an allied country that has one of the largest US military bases in the region. But please, I'm all ears. What have you got, that makes the above so mundane and unsurprising? I look forward to learning.
- squozzer 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J._Edgar_Hoover https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J._Edgar_Hoover http://ocean.otr.usm.edu/~w304644/ajha/americanjournalism/fall09.pdf http://ocean.otr.usm.edu/~w304644/ajha/americanjournalism/fa... "During the Civil War the federal government was responsible for the greatest amount of newspaper suppression in the nation’s history. More than 300 newspapers were shut down, most of them Democratic papers that were sympathetic to the Confederacy. Some historians have criticized President Abraham Lincoln for allowing such widespread constraints on the press. This article reconsiders the nature of Lincoln’s view of press freedom. Based on a letter the president sent to a Union general, it concludes that Lincoln changed his thinking about midway through the war and began to believe that suppression of the press was not the appropriate policy."
- coryfklein 8y ago> People are acting all shocked like this is a new state of affairs. Wait, they are? Who?
- abrahamepton 8y agoMe. I would say that this is an entirely novel state of affairs, without precedent in American history. As others have pointed out to me in this thread, "American history" contains lots of pretty salacious and wild stories of governmental abuse of authority. Yet all the jaded Hacker News historians around here haven't really pointed out any actual incidents in history that approach this story. "You should read about Hoover" or "Abraham Lincoln did some bad shit during the Civil War" doesn't really approach the level of "President conspiring with two separate foreign adversaries/frenemies to undermine American elections, enrich himself and blackmail his enemies" to say nothing of all the juicy details we don't yet know.