2 ms·
> All we are saying is that in the United States, what the Supreme Court says on this issue _categorically_ makes it constitutional This is a political asserti
by mindslight 8y ago
> All we are saying is that in the United States, what the Supreme Court says on this issue _categorically_ makes it constitutional
This is a political assertion you are making. It prevents invoking the intent of the constitution without some contextual disclaimer, thus hindering critiques of whether the current government has run aground of its charter.
> There are groups that think all of those decisions were bad and unconstitutional -- but the Supreme Court has the final say
The final say over whether the government considers an action constitutional! While the Supreme Court interprets the law for the government, it does not have a monopoly on the definition of the word "constitutional".
Please note that my original comment even used the term "anticonstitutional", because I did somewhat anticipate this authoritarian fallacy that courts define truth. Regardless of arguing the semantics of whether "constitutional" and "unconstitutional" are constrained to only referencing the legal scope, the argument I'm making is that the practice of stopping and harassing every traveler runs directly contrary to what the founders intended as well as the values our society purports to hold.