> That's verbatim what happened! I call BS. Money is fungible, so "of the $10 we gave the driver, $5 was from you and $5 was from us" doesn't mean anything out

> That's verbatim what happened! I call BS. Money is fungible, so "of the $10 we gave the driver, $5 was from you and $5 was from us" doesn't mean anything outside of the stories we tell. All that happened in terms of bank transactions was that you gave Amazon $5, and Amazon gave the driver $10. That said, there is a good way to tell whether they're getting your tip or not. Ask how much more money the specific driver you tipped received than if you hadn't tipped. That's right, $0. (On the other hand, I bet if you tipped more than the base pay, the driver would get that much. So big enough tips probably make a difference.) Though what really matters is what the courts say :-).