6 ms·
> “Your app uses analytics software to collect and send user or device data to a third party without the user’s consent. Apps must request explicit user consent
by minimaxir 8y ago
> “Your app uses analytics software to collect and send user or device data to a third party without the user’s consent. Apps must request explicit user consent and provide a clear visual indication when recording, logging, or otherwise making a record of user activity,”
Every big app collects analytics without such disclosure (and definitely no visual indicator). I honestly can't think of a counterexample.
If Apple's declaration is taken literally, this will have massive fallout on the analytics ecosystem.
- threeseed 8y agoNot every big app. Every app. It can often be difficult to determine root cause of an issue when you are just given a stack trace. I suspect we will soon see two patterns arise: (1) Popups when the app launches to get consent and (2) Screen recording that still happens but only phones home if an exception occurs and where they get consent at that point. And what does this mean for core metrics like Google Analytics ?
- mcny 8y agoI sincerely doubt Google would send ANYTHING to a third party unless it really had to. That being said I think this is a good compromise and I hope Apple applies this to all vendors. I think the biggest winner here if I read this correctly is AWS and other cloud providers. The most straightforward way for someone like mouseflow to comply is to separate each customer to its own instance in a way that mouseflow has no access to user data.
- glitchc 8y agoHuh? Google’s entire revenue model is based on advertising. Of course they send your info to a “third-party,” that party being the advertiser(s).
- ForHackernews 8y agoGooglers will insist that they don't "send" your info to the advertisers, they only let advertisers buy ads based on that info.
- cosmie 8y agoI'm a non-Googler who has spent a lot of time around media analytics, and I'll make the same insistence that that is a true and important statement. Google is a one way mirror. They will suck in as much data as you want to give them about people, but it's virtually impossible to pry any info out of Google that's at an individual and identifiable level. Only aggregated performance information is exposed to advertisers, and the ability to mix and match targeting criteria based off of those dimensions that they expose. Even with their enterprise marketing products like DoubleClick you can't pry out individual-level data. DoubleClick customers used to be able to export an anonymous ID, so they could use independent third-parties to consolidate conversion and impression data and measure attribution across complex marketing campaigns. But even that isn't possible anymore, due to GDPR concerns[1]. The closest they now get to "sharing" user data is Ads Data Hub[2]. And by sharing, I mean they expect you to share all of your data from outside of Google, which Google will then connect to their data and allow you the privilege of running aggregated queries. But they actually keep their side of the data firewalled off, and it's not human readable or accessible at the row level, only in rollup queries. In the ad world, I can assure you they are far more protective of user data than most anyone else. The size, effectiveness, and dominance of their marketing channels afford them the ability to take that position without it materially impacting advertiser spending. Very few advertisers take such active measures to insulate exposure of user data from advertisers. And for many that do invest resources in such endeavors, it doesn't mean that they don't provide user data to advertisers. It just means that they don't provide it for free anymore. [1] https://adage.com/article/digital/google-s-move-remove-doubleclick-id-presents-issues/313415/ https://adage.com/article/digital/google-s-move-remove-doubl... [2] https://developers.google.com/ads-data-hub/ https://developers.google.com/ads-data-hub/
- glitchc 8y agoI see, and stand corrected. Must presume this is as long as they never get desperate (a la Yahoo).
- jpollock 8y agoGoogle doesn't have to send your data to a third party to get advertising revenue. The advertiser creates and advertisement and passes it to Google with a selector, "We want to show this advertisement to men over the age of 35 in Milwaukee" and a price/click. When someone who fits the selector arrives, the advertisement enters into Google's auction. If it wins the auction, it's rendered to the customer. Google doesn't say "Here's the list of our customers, and who they are, let me know who you want to send ads to". https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/1704368?hl=en https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/1704368?hl=en
- cosmie 8y ago> I sincerely doubt Google would send ANYTHING to a third party unless it really had to. In this context, Google is the third party. Plenty of apps use the Google Analytics SDK[1], or the newer GA Firebase SDK[2] for their analytics. [1] https://developers.google.com/analytics/devguides/collection/ios/v3/ https://developers.google.com/analytics/devguides/collection... [2] https://firebase.google.com/docs/analytics/ios/start https://firebase.google.com/docs/analytics/ios/start
- 0x0 8y agoI have published several apps on the App Store and none of them make use of any analytics or screen recording or any telemetry, really. So your statement "every app" is categorically wrong as far as I can understand it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bhelkey 8y agoWhat kind of metrics can you get from Apple. Clearly number of downloads, but how about things like Daily Active Users?
- saagarjha 8y agoQuite a bit, actually: daily active users, retention rates by day, sessions are among the things you can view.
- zeroimpl 8y agoAnd if your app has any kind of online component, there's probably an HTTP request hitting your server whenever the user launches the app. So even without explicit telemetry in the app, you can easily get decent data from your web server's logs.
- messick 8y agoHere you go: https://developer.apple.com/app-store-connect/analytics/ https://developer.apple.com/app-store-connect/analytics/
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- EGreg 8y agoWell maybe it will help OPEN SOURCE technologies like Matomo spring up and you can, I don't know, OWN YOUR OWN DATA and pay for your own hosting.
- h3throw 8y agoYou didn't pay attention to the key part "to a third party". Most of the larger companies don't use third party logging software, AFAIK.
- briandear 8y agoThe first party already has your data under their own privacy policy. But users aren’t necessarily agreeing to the privacy policies of third parties when they use an app.
- guelo 8y agoThat's not true. Most companies offload analytics to a third party such as Google Analytics or Mixpanel.
- jug 8y agoOhh, I wonder if this is related to why Apple is doing this. It benefits the end user but also punishes app developers who rely on Google.
- saagarjha 8y ago> It benefits the end user There's your reason.
- LeoNatan25 8y agoHow funny that "benefits end user" and "punishes ... Google" are in the same sentence in such a nonchalant way.
- jayd16 8y agoDropping all analytics and crash reporting hurts the product and by extension the user.
- saagarjha 8y ago
- guelo 8y agoYea Apple needs to clarify what is allowed and what is not. Keeping track of user clicks is pretty much industry standard.
- Pharmakon 8y agoI believe Apple just used their weight to declare that industry standard is, as we already know, anti-customer and anti-privacy. I suspect they’ve realized that beyond the iPhone and iPad, their biggest advantage is that they have history of respecting user privacy. Leaning into that when companies like Google literally can’t because spying on people is the core business model, is pretty smart.
- glitchc 8y agoI’ve seen them in action, these frameworks do way more. They record touches, delays between touches, sensor info, key logs, including mistypes. Watching the playback of the collected data against the backdrop of the app is like watching a remote desktop session.
- saagarjha 8y ago> Yea Apple needs to clarify what is allowed and what is not. Apple explicitly does not do this, because they know that they'll draw a line and two months later someone will try to get through on a technicality.
- avip 8y agoAnd likewise big chunk of cybersecurity.
- duskwuff 8y agoThere is a pretty significant difference between recording users' activities at an abstract, aggregate level (e.g, to measure DAU and user retention, or to track how many users use a feature or complete a funnel), and recording the activities of individual users at the highly specific level used by Glassbox. I suspect that Apple's statement is meant to target the latter, not all analytics as a whole.
- minimaxir 8y agoI agree, which is why the exact verbiage on Apple's end is important.
- tyingq 8y agoThere's a fair number of vendors that "record" web sessions too. Not via a screenshot, but the difference isn't much to a lay person. They track mouse movements, key up/down, etc. Enough to credibly recreate a "video" of sorts. Apple would have a harder time banning that.
- thekyle 8y ago> Apple would have a harder time banning that. Well, obviously Apple cannot ban what is outside of its walled garden.
- tyingq 8y agoI'm not sure about that. They certainly control which browser apis they choose to support. And it seems like those that support web applications getting closer to native apps functionality are the ones they lag on.
- AlexandrB 8y ago> If Apple's declaration is taken literally, this will have massive fallout on the analytics ecosystem. Good. I don't know when it became OK to log just about everything a user does in your app (or operating system, in the case of Windows 10) "just in case". It's creepy, often unnecessary, and prioritizes the convenience of the developer over the user's right to privacy.
- jabberthemutt 8y agoEspecially since software UX has not become significantly better as a result.
- rocqua 8y agoI wonder whether UX monetization has or whether the analytics haven't had any effect at all.
- toper-centage 8y agoExactly. Only "conversion".
- woshea901 8y agoWe got a 24 hour mandate to upload a tracking free version. Fuck you Apple. "Your lack of preparedness is not my emergency." My European dev team is now up at almost 1am on Saturday putting in a fix for this. Unless Apple themselves is going to provide tools to help make better, crash-free software, these are necessary third party tools.