3 ms·
> No you wouldn't. That is an unusually juvenile response for HN. You don't get to determine what other people want, even if they are stupid. > It's like plac
by roenxi 8y ago
> No you wouldn't.
That is an unusually juvenile response for HN. You don't get to determine what other people want, even if they are stupid.
> It's like placing a market order to sell AAPL and then being upset that your shares sold for $20 each.
It is nothing alike; your analogy is incoherent. AlphaGo is claimed to be hopelessly inefficient vs a human yet has an amazing track record at winning Go, and whatever your analogy is meant to mean, there is no comparison between losing money on shares and effortlessly competing with every expert in a field.
I didn't say give up efficiency and see what happens, I said when choosing between better results and better efficiency, I'd prefer results.
> Note also that your stated preference makes complexity theory irrelevant, as a brute force approach to solving any problem already achieves the theoretical optimum. Do you really want to claim that that's true?
It doesn't make complexity theory irrelevant, at some point problems become so complex you can't solve them with brute force because of physical limits. Up to that point, if I have an optimal solution and you don't, then yes I think I'm doing better than you. Efficiency is great, but not if you don't get results.
> No, you can't, except to the extent that you're assuming your body's existing limits on the amount of energy it will consume
Ok, assume that :P. Duh. A human can apparently exert about 80 Watts sustained [0] and a Gen 1 Google TPU is 40 Watts [1]. Google's laptop might use 4 of the things, but AlphaGo Zero is pretty strong, and we know from LeelaZero that you don't need a TPU to be able to crush a human professional. We aren't approaching the limits of physics or biology here. Even if biology couldn't handle it for some reason, the point is I'd rather use a TPU for thinking about Go than not, because for all that people wring their hands about what it means to think, clearly computers are better at making competitive decisions. If you'd prefer to lose efficiently, I can't stop you, but you aren't going to be winning any prizes if I use a TPU and you don't.
> That assumption means you accept that your body knows better than you what tradeoffs to make.
This is wrong. The next time you use a bicycle, train or car [2] you can reflect that you managed to make yourself look stupid on the internet. They make very different trade offs to a human and get much better results on efficiency and speed depending on what you prefer. If you were restricted to the tradeoffs your body made in transport, modern society would collapse and you'd probably starve to death or be eaten by a mob of city dwellers looking for food. Intelligence is going down the same path, where the tradeoffs that the body made are just not good enough for the context we operate in.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_power https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_power
[1] https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/269008-google-announces-8x-faster-tpu-3-0-for-ai-machine-learning https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/269008-google-announces-...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_efficiency_in_transport https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_efficiency_in_transport
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> You don't get to determine what other people want, even if they are stupid. Sure, but in this case it's very easy to state with 100% confidence that you said you wanted something which you don't actually want. That's stupid, but it's a different kind of stupidity than wanting something you won't like. Compare how I described your problem: >> That's what you said you wanted. But it wasn't what you actually wanted.