3 ms·
Most 3D films are shot in 2D and converted in post, unfortunately. It’s very common. See: https://realorfake3d.com/ https://realorfake3d.com/ Edit: To be clea
by klodolph 8y ago
Most 3D films are shot in 2D and converted in post, unfortunately. It’s very common.
See: https://realorfake3d.com/ https://realorfake3d.com/
Edit: To be clear, I'm saying that since most 3D films aren't shot in 3D in the first place, this film probably won't be substantially different from other films, in 3D. It seems some people thought I was confused about what the movie was.
- nicklaf 8y agoWait a minute, think about what you are talking about here for a second! :-)
- drcode 8y agoLOL this is true, but kind of off the mark... given that the whole point of this movie is to augment low quality movie footage with post-processing.
- klodolph 8y agoIsn't that what I'm saying? How am I off the mark?
- rspeele 8y agoI think klodolph's point is still on the mark. I don't read it as: "The 3D in this WWI footage was faked in post." Which is obviously true. I instead read it as: "The reason the 3D looks about as good as you're used to from other films, is that most of those modern films _also_ faked their 3D in post."
- wnissen 8y agoSpecifically, Jackson et al. chose a 3D conversion company to do the coloring, because one of the steps in a conversion is to separate out the various parts of the frame. So much of the work was already done. I "liked" this movie, as much as anyone can like seeing dead bodies. It really makes you realize how much most war movies, fiction or not, leave out. I wonder to what extent the lack of the true horrors results in a pro-war propaganda film, regardless of the intent of the director. Kubrick's Full Metal Jacket tries to be realistic in a sense, but still glamorizes war. It takes a documentary like "They Shall Not Grow Old" to give the full picture.
- icebraining 8y agoKubrick has a better example in Paths of Glory. It's still not very gruesome, but in the single combat scene of the whole movie, the soldiers don't get to fire a single shot, they just advance and die.