4 ms·
No mention of ending inflation, which is a deliberate state-driven policy to steal from the poor to give to the rich and make the state "look good" by lowering
by dnautics 8y ago
No mention of ending inflation, which is a deliberate state-driven policy to steal from the poor to give to the rich and make the state "look good" by lowering the metric of unemployment:
https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/13/the-case-for-higher-inflation/ https://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/13/the-case-for-hi...
"even in the long run, it’s really, really hard to cut nominal wages. Yet when you have very low inflation, getting relative wages right would require that a significant number of workers take wage cuts. So having a somewhat higher inflation rate would lead to lower unemployment, not just temporarily, but on a sustained basis."
- FiveSquared 8y agoIn heath care, education, etc. It is deliberate. Otherwise, it is due to the natural change in the economy. Prices will always rise as more money is in the country. In a theoretical free market, inflation always exists due to the money supply as more money is required. The Fed is tampering with the money supply to induce growth. Growth in money supply = inflation in a vacuum.
- mruts 8y agoWhat are you talking about? The point of inflation is to encourage the spending and investment of money. It doesn’t really have anything to do with unemployment.
- dnautics 8y agoFine, if that's what you believe is the point of inflation. Whom does "investment" benefit? Go down to the tenderloin in SF, look around, and ask yourself if these people are benefitted by 'investment'. And the mechanism, as indicated in the quote, has at least a side effect of lowering the real value of workers (his words, not mine) wages. Inflation is exactly stealing from the poor to give to the wealthy. There's a reason why the income gap turned in mid 70s when Nixon closed the gold window; we can never hope to fix income inequality with linear downward redistributive policy until the compounding, upward redistribution is stopped.
- mruts 8y agoYou’re getting this backwards. Inflation helps the poor because the rich are much more likely to invest in job creation (by spending money and hiring people), when we have inflation. deflation is terrible for the poor, unemployment goes up and job creation goes down. If you look at historical data of inflation vs unemployment I’m sure you’ll come to the same conclusion. If the money supply doesn’t increase, it’s actually deflationary, due to population growth. If inflation is 0, it means that the money supply is increasing at the same rate as production. To provide good incentives, you want the money supply to slightly outpace the growth in production. Which is what 1-2% inflation precisely does. Clearly, super inflation is distinctly bad for the poor, but that’s different from inflation that slightly out paces population growth. Almost all economists are of the same opinion.
- mindslight 8y ago> deflation is terrible for the poor, unemployment goes up and job creation goes down Yes, this is the standard assertion that is continually repeated to justify the state policy of overwhelming monetary inflation. But it presupposes that what makes people poor is simply a lack of employment, rather than being unable to keep up with their essential expenses. Of course if you personally benefit from there being more minimum wage workers, this makes perfect sense to you - if 40 hours a week at minimum wage is not enough for someone to pay their bills, they can simply find another job and work 80! But if you instead consider someone who does have a constant job that we accept as "full time", then having the real purchasing power of their salary generally trending down is certainly doing them no favors. That is the wage theft of inflation.
- mruts 8y agoThat someone will get raises, assuming they are doing something in which their skills matter. A checkout cashier probably won't, because their job is a commodity, i.e, it doesn't matter if they are good or bad at their job, the results will be the same. If someone has skills in which there is competition, lets say a factory workers (there is a tangible difference between the best factory worker and the worst), they will see their wages rise due to inflation. Because of inflation more investment capital will flow into the factory company, and the company will have more money to try and select the "best" factory workers. The competition for labor will then drive up the wages up the factory worker .
- iooi 8y agoI recommend taking an Economics course. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phillips_curve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phillips_curve
- jiveturkey 8y agoa. isn't krugman arguing FOR inflation? b. why is low unemployment bad? let's say we have a deflationary economy, doesn't that lead to high unemployment which is a feedback to more deflation? how is that not a bad thing? excuse my naivete
- dnautics 8y agoHis arguing for inflation, exactly. And read the quote. The way it works is by stealing from workers. > "let's say we have a deflationary economy, doesn't that lead to high unemployment which is a feedback to more deflation" I suppose in a deflationary economy the equilibrium state is no one will have a job?
- mindslight 8y ago> why is low unemployment bad? Low unemployment isn't inherently bad as an indicator, but attempting to force low unemployment with monetary policy is. In this context, lowering unemployment means increasing the financial pressure on workers so they accept lower wages. Meanwhile technological progress is eliminating many traditional positions, so workers end up stuck between a rock and a hard place - the screws are being turned on them so they go out and look for a job harder, yet there's nothing to be found!
- logfromblammo 8y agoInflation is the Keynesian economist's tool for cutting wages without letting the wage-employees know that their wages are being cut. Monetary inflation (and monetary deflation) benefit those closest to the monetary authority, those with information advantage, and those with pricing power at the expense of everyone else. If you know what the Fed will do, you get richer. If you can get the new money first, you get richer. If you are holding money when old money is destroyed, you get richer. The economy works best when the growth in the money supply exactly matches the growth in economic activity. The Fed targets a positive inflation rate for several reasons, but one of them is that it makes real wages fall at a steady rate, and therefore workers become cheaper over time, encouraging hiring. If more wages were keyed to the inflation rate with automatic raises, the exercise would be pointless. Always-inflation monetary policy means that everyone who works gets a pay cut, all the time. It's a stupid accounting trick, and it only works on paper. In practice, it means that the lowest-paid workers, with the least wage-bargaining power, are constantly slipping closer to poverty. But hey, they can always find a job that is decreasingly able to pay all their bills, right? Low unemployment is not inherently bad. It is bad when you are screwing with the numbers just to hide bigger problems in your economy that may be contributing to a high unemployment rate.
- mindslight 8y agoFrom the OP: > The real constraint only kicks in when there’s too much spending relative to a limited supply of goods and services—in other words, when inflation spikes. And there’s been little sign of that in America for decades. It amazes me that this can still be repeated with a straight face. The prices for housing, healthcare, and education have skyrocketed - many would say that the costs for these are the problem. What is happening is that technological and economic progression are continually trying to lower the prices of consumer goods. Rather than let this natural deflation occur, the overt monetary policy is to inject new money in the consumer sector until average prices rise instead. But this money isn't given directly to consumers as cash, but only supplied as loans through financing channels. People don't have an extra ten dollars to spend on groceries (which would make grocery prices rise), but an extra $1,000 to borrow and bid up financializable assets. The monthly payments to service the debt (sometimes called rent) are also mandatory, so their financial position becomes ever more dependent on continual income.
- dnautics 8y agoDrop a line!
- gniv 8y ago> No mention of ending inflation Did you mean to say "No mention of ending low inflation"? Otherwise your comment doesn't make sense to me.