3 ms·
To me the concept of labor in socialism is outdated. Consider Facebook, do all the uses who generate the content and activity that gives Facebook its value coun
by chasd00 8y ago
To me the concept of labor in socialism is outdated. Consider Facebook, do all the uses who generate the content and activity that gives Facebook its value count towards "labor" and therefore should participate in the rewards of that labor?
If everything was still physical factories, staffed by humans, and creating physical widgets then I can at least understand the socialist view. However, in the current market labor so is detached from profit it doesn't make a lot of sense.
- lifeisstillgood 8y ago>>> do all the uses who generate the content and activity that gives Facebook its value count towards "labor" and therefore should participate in the rewards of that labor? yes. I have contributed a small part of labor, but probably more importantly I have sold my Intellectual Property - my Personal data, to Facebook who then monetise it and give me no cut of the proceeds. It is an interesting framework from fallingfrog. I like it
- chasd00 8y agoIf you sold them something then you should send them an invoice. Or, did you agree to their terms and conditions of using their website/mobile app voluntarily? This makes no sense to me.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoto make an (extreme and not equal example) you can enter a contract to sell your liver - society has decided that such contracts should be illegal. we shall probably make a similar decision on selling personal data.
- claudiawerner 8y ago>Consider Facebook, do all the uses who generate the content and activity that gives Facebook its value count towards "labor" It is labour, so yes. What do you think the concept of labour in socialism is? Only then can we judge if it is inaccurate. For instance, Marx never excluded mental/information-work/management labour, and in fact he mentioned them specifically at many points.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoI was seriously just thinking that I'd like to see a Marxist analysis of this from you. So please, keep going. My initial attempt at it: Facebook is the capitalist, owning the means of production. The workers aren't the employees of Facebook (I mean, yes, those are workers too, but they aren't the ones we're concerned about here). Instead, the workers are the users who generate the content. Facebook profits by keeping the fruits of their labor (their content). What would it look like for the workers to own the means of production?