2 ms·
Star Trek serialized it (seemingly) easily enough. They essentially got a new universe of problems to explore every episode with the context of the Federations
by ianai 8y ago
Star Trek serialized it (seemingly) easily enough. They essentially got a new universe of problems to explore every episode with the context of the Federations technology and administration.
- rsynnott 8y agoStar Trek's society never made much _sense_, though. If you exclude all the utopian speeches given by Picard, and just look at the interaction of the Federation and Starfleet, you could be forgiven for thinking it was a military dictatorship. (Pet theory; the Federation is a Soviet-ish military command economy. The episodes we see are in-universe propaganda produced by the state. That's why everyone is so heroic, and why all of the rival civilisations are mostly one-dimensional stereotypes.) I think Banks' Culture is a better example of a utopia played straight, but most of the action in those novels takes place largely outside the Culture.
- krapp 8y ago>That's why everyone is so heroic, and why all of the rival civilisations are mostly one-dimensional stereotypes. That is literally what they are, they're intended to act as mirrors to various aspects of humanity, or embody singular aspects of the plot of the week.
- labster 8y agoShaka, when the walls fell.
- krapp 8y agoDon't get me started on Darmok. I don't understand why that episode is so praised, it makes no sense. How... HOW do you have a technological, much less warp capable, civilization if you only speak in metaphor and allegory? How do engineers get anything done? Do they write white papers in metaphors? Do the captains of their ships issue orders in metaphors? Languages don't work like that. They literally can't work like that. It literally makes me... mildly annoyed.
- labster 8y agoThe media, when Kanye tweeted.
- ianai 8y agoIt’s also not like we’re told the federation has had complete access to everything about the society. There could be more traditional stories shared with their children as a basis for the language, but unshared with the federation. All language lives within a culture, and words only convey meaning through a mutually shared understanding. They’ve made allegories first class parts of language, the equivalent to our individual words.