3 ms·
> My theory is that, instead, the brain is a super-duper complex neural network with some differences about how the update of the weights happen Neural network
by jcranmer 8y ago
> My theory is that, instead, the brain is a super-duper complex neural network with some differences about how the update of the weights happen
Neural networks were not meant to be accurate analogues to the actual operation of the neurons in the brain. They were known to be poor matches for the actual biology, even back in 1959. The concept of the multilayer neural network was actually inspired from our knowledge of the visual cortex, rather than the lower-level fundamentals of the brain. The brain is most certainly not a neural network, as the term is understood in machine learning.
- skohan 8y ago> The brain is most certainly not a neural network, as the term is understood in machine learning. The brain is most certainly a neural network. It is literally a network of neurons. But you're right insofar that artificial neural networks are not very similar to the brain.
- tptacek 8y agoThat is exactly what the parent comment said.
- skohan 8y agoI was objecting to the statement: "The brain is most certainly not a neural network" - as if to say that the types of artificial neural networks employed in machine learning are somehow the central definition of what a neural network is. I would be happy with "the brain is not an ANN", or "The brain is very different from the types of neural networks used in Machine Learning", but to say the brain is anything other than a neural network is just plain wrong.
- tptacek 8y agoThat's not what they said. They said, "The brain is most certainly not a neural network, as the term is understood in machine learning.".
- skohan 8y agoI understand what they said. That statement reads: "Machine learning has a concept of a neural network, and the brain is not that". A correct statement would be: "The field of machine learning makes use of a computing system called an artificial neural network, which is loosely based on the structure and function of a biological neural network." The statement in question would be like saying: "Italians most certainly do not make real coffee, as the term is understood at Starbucks." There's a technically correct reading of that sentence, but the implication is offensive to the subject matter.