4 ms·
My theory? The virulent strain of anti-intellectualism / anti-elitism that has run through American society in the last 20 years. "These fancy educated people i
by walrus01 8y ago
My theory? The virulent strain of anti-intellectualism / anti-elitism that has run through American society in the last 20 years. "These fancy educated people in their ivory towers telling me what to do with my children...".
There's a point at which you should simply defer to the critical mass of thousands of people with doctorates in the subject matter, such as about 99.9% of epidemiologists on the planet.
- mindslight 8y agoI've been thinking a lot on the anti-intellectualism lately. Lower intelligence people are less able to judge whether an idea is sensible on its own merits. Furthermore, they are likely to be outwitted by people with higher intelligence. So their mode of operation becomes to not even attempt judging an idea by its merits, lest they end up fooled. Rather, they judge based solely on the perceived stature of whom the idea is coming from. The breakdown of our media institutions furthers the problem - rather than presenting an opinionated application of common sense that condemns poor ideas, they've devolved into giving "each side" equal time to obscure their true power of defining what subjects are talked about. So once these memes get out there, they keep circulating as folk wisdom continually re-validated by appearances in mainstream media.
- FooHentai 8y agoBut it begs the question. What's underpinning that as the root cause for what we're now seeing? My money's mainly on the loss of prestige surrounding the teaching profession, and loss of the elite status of high education. It's simply not valued as it once was, and as a result everyone's 'highly' educated while simultaneously quite poorly educated, at least outside of stuff that is scored on tests. As the parent post says, 'Critical' reasoning/thinking skills are demonstrably lacking. Reading back what I just wrote, I'm certainly entering 'old man yells at cloud' years of my life it seems :)
- torpfactory 8y agoI think the reason is the vast change in communication technologies (i.e. the internet) in the last 20 years. People used to mostly be exposed to only the pro-vax side which was available from their doctor, in person. There simply wasn't an efficient avenue for anti-vax sentiment to spread. Now any yahoo with a Facebook account can post their zany ideas. In fact, these technologies are almost tailored to spread the zaniest ideas. People are exposed to these ideas often in social media, making them believe they are also common. This breaks down the barrier which might have previously prevented people from believing in fringe ideas: they are now exposed to them frequently. As for the 'average citizen', I don't think the general public has EVER really had critical thinking or reasoning skills. I would bet only 5-10% of the population has the scientific literacy skills to really make sense of the statistics and scientific reasoning which so strongly supports vaccination. Without the ability to make sense for themselves, many are left with appeals to emotion or authority for guidance. As authority loses ground in a sea of new voices on social media, only emotion and fear (much of it unfounded) remains.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rdtsc 8y ago> "These fancy educated people in their ivory towers telling me what to do with my children...". I have seen college educated people including those with advanced degrees who just as easily if not more so pedal anti-vaxxing bullshit. No, they are not scientists, but they and their peers would consider themselves intellectuals. > you should simply defer to the critical mass of thousands of people with doctorates I noticed a paradox in that people who have doctorates in unrelated fields just as easily decide that they can research on their own and other doctors might just not be as "smart". Unlike flat earth, contrails and other such bullshit, anti-vaxxing does seem to attract educated people as well as uneducated ones. Even if you read the article, I wouldn't consider Washington state as the epicenter of anti-intellectualism in US. Quite the opposite I would say.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoWe shouldn’t let someone who doesn’t understand evolution and probability to consider themselves educated. Those concepts should be required to be learned in high school, and not be able to pass without them.
- rdtsc 8y ago> We shouldn’t let someone who doesn’t understand evolution Agree yeah. The difficult part is that a lot of these people think they understand evolution. Overall Clark County, WA doesn't seem to be a hotbed of uneducated people, about 30% of adults have college degrees there which is about average for US as well I think. At least it's not as simple as pointing and saying "Ah, look only 5% of people there went to college of course they be anti-intellectual with all the associate risks of following conspiracy theories" but it seems something more complex is happening there.