4 ms·
Definitions don't belong to committees. "open source" isn't a trademarked or otherwise protected phrase, it does not belong to the OSI, it is not synonymous wi
by colechristensen 8y ago
Definitions don't belong to committees.
"open source" isn't a trademarked or otherwise protected phrase, it does not belong to the OSI, it is not synonymous with (has an)"open source initiative Approved License".
Coining a term or being among the first to use it does not mean that term belongs to you.
There are many people that disagree with the OSI about what "open source" means, and that is what it takes for a definition.
There is a certain irony in the OSI talking about open source like they own it.
- rangerpolitic 8y ago> Coining a term or being among the first to use it does not mean that term belongs to you. I wish that people would understand this not only in the context of definitions but also in the context of culture. Neither definitions nor culture belong to anyone. At the same time, they "belong" to everyone.
- colechristensen 8y agoSelf-replying to nail down what I strongly disagree with: >Can I call my program "Open Source" even if I don't use an approved license? >Please don't do that. If you call it "Open Source" without using an approved license, you will confuse people. This is not merely a theoretical concern — we have seen this confusion happen in the past, and it's part of the reason we have a formal license approval process. See also our page on license proliferation for why this is a problem. This is from their FAQ and an example of the OSI explicitly acting like they own "open source". I am fine with proprietary terms being owned and controlled, for example "USB". I am not fine with organizations trying to usurp the language to try to push forward their agenda regardless of their intentions (and generally I approve of the mission of OSI)
- LamaOfRuin 8y agoThey're not usurping it. They literally created it as a term (and "brand") rather than simply two words. They weren't granted a trademark, so their creation of it has no legal weight, but that doesn't mean they can't claim authority over what it means, and ask that their original intent be respected.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> This is from their FAQ and an example of the OSI explicitly acting like they own "open source" No, if they were acting like they owned the term, they’d say “No, and we'll take coercive action to stop you if you do.” What they are actually saying is (in short) “Please don't, experience has shown it causes confusion.”
- benatkin 8y agoThey don't own the trademark, but they could have, had the USPTO ruled differently. Much less exclusive terms, like Apple, have been trademarked. To many in the open source community, myself included, when we hear open source we think of the open source initiative, opensource.org, and/or their logo. I'm not bothered by your viewpoint. Sure, we don't own the trademark, but to me, open source is and long has been the culture that emerged out of the early days of building an open source operating system (Linux, GNU/Linux, *BSD, etc). If you want "open source" to be a meaningless term, I'd first suggest trying to convince OSI to part ways with opensource.org. I don't think it's for sale, but maybe you could infiltrate the organization. Many have tried.
- geofft 8y agoEnglish is not a prescriptive language: there is no committee with whom you can register a meaning. But that means that meanings are determined by how people use the term, and the OSI is claiming that what people generally mean by the term is the OSD, and backing up that claim with signatories. It's of course possible to choose to mean something different by "kilogram." Nobody has trademarked the word. But the word nonetheless has a clear and well-accepted meaning, and someone who uses "kilogram" to mean "the weight of a liter of water from my tap right now" is using a nonstandard and potentially confusing definition. That's the point of their analogy.
- colechristensen 8y ago>It's of course possible to choose to mean something different by "kilogram." Nobody has trademarked the word. But the word nonetheless has a clear and well-accepted meaning, and someone who uses "kilogram" to mean "the weight of a liter of water from my tap right now" is using a nonstandard and potentially confusing definition. That's the point of their analogy. This is a very bad example. If I were to go to your grocery store and buy a kilogram of apples from you, but your "kilogram" was a weight invented by you, you would be breaking the law. More or less every country has legal definitions of weights and measures. They are not "common usage" but very strictly prescribed. OSI is trying hard to prescribe the meaning of a term they have no rights to.
- mindcrime 8y agoIt's not a "de jure" standard, but it is a "de facto" standard. In every meaningful sense, the OSD is the definition of "Open Source".
- type0 8y ago> There are many people that disagree with the OSI about what "open source" means, and that is what it takes for a definition. > There is a certain irony in the OSI talking about open source like they own it. They defined it, there are many people that disagree that the Earth is spherical -it's still doesn't make it true.
- wmf 8y agoArguably OSI took the DFSG, which was understood to only apply to Debian, renamed it the OSD, and then tried to apply it to the whole OSS movement.
- massonpj 8y ago> "Definitions don't belong to committees" > "[...]irony in the OSI talking about open source like they own it[...]" The definition (and it's authority/legitimacy) belongs to (i.e. owned by) a community of contributors, very much like an open source project, not a committee (i.e. the OSI Board of Directors). Currently there are 508 members in the OSI's "License Discuss", and 266 members in the "License Review" communities. These are open to anyone to join, and participate in. These groups define "open source" as expressed trough licensing. The Open Source Definition, as well as OSI Approved Open Source Licenses have been modified through the consensus of these communities (e.g. the addition of a 10th criterion to the OSD, and work around open source license proliferation). (Full disclosure, I am currently the General Manager at the OSI).