3 ms·
Well banning them certainly would have led to many families being worse off in the short term (lost income) and coal prices increasing (reduced labor pool). The
by kortilla 8y ago
Well banning them certainly would have led to many families being worse off in the short term (lost income) and coal prices increasing (reduced labor pool). The analysis needs to be compared against alternative policies that would have discouraged it through market pressure (e.g. free school for children with a free meal) rather than an outright ban.
Don’t ban the undesirable thing, figure out why people are doing the undesirable thing in the first place and address that.
Btw the children example is bad because there is an entirely separate argument about the child not being old enough to make decisions that completely muddies the point.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>Btw the children example is bad because there is an entirely separate argument about the child not being old enough to make decisions that completely muddies the point. It used to be that kids were treated like little adults and were considered fully capable of decision making. Now it seems like a lot of people want adults to be treated like kids and protected (if you can call it that) from opportunities to make bad decisions.