7 ms·
Isn't this what trademarks are for? If they want to enforce what the meaning of a term is in a a given domain they could come up with a new term and trademark i
by chrisseaton 8y ago
Isn't this what trademarks are for? If they want to enforce what the meaning of a term is in a a given domain they could come up with a new term and trademark it.
- sparkie 8y agoYes, but open source was already used before the OSI came about. I don't think anyone knows exactly who coined it and when. OSI is trademarked, and they are in their rights to defend that trademark, but that obviously does not extend to "open source." This statement is an attempted protectionist power grab to assert control over the term and prevent competing initiatives from using it.
- rmmm 8y agoIt's pretty well known who coined open source and why. It's also known shortly thereafter OSI started protecting the definition. https://opensource.com/article/18/2/coining-term-open-source-software https://opensource.com/article/18/2/coining-term-open-source... https://opensource.org/history https://opensource.org/history
- tzs 8y agoIt may have been used before they did in the context of computer software, but if so such usage seems to have been very sparse. I tried to research it once, a long time ago, and my recollection is that I found maybe one or two possible examples on Usenet but nothing else.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> It may have been used before they did in the context of computer software I'm pretty sure the use in intelligence jargon long predates the software use. But that's disambiguated easily by context, it's not really a conflicting use.
- wmf 8y agoThe term "open source" is not a trademark and at this point it probably cannot be trademarked by anyone. In uncontroversial cases people are happy to let the OSI be the arbiter of open sourceness but in controversial cases people tend to decide that OSI doesn't control the meaning of open source.
- zzzcpan 8y agoOSI actually attempted to trademark "open source" and failed.
- chrisseaton 8y agoThat's my point. It isn't a trademark. They should come up with something new that is. 'OSI Approved' would be fine.
- wmf 8y agoNobody would ever care about new terminology.
- massonpj 8y agoThe term "open source" can not be trademarked (just like Kilogram can not); the mark is too "descriptive." The OSI does have trademarks for "OSI Approved Open Source License", as well of course for its own branding, e.g. the "OSI Keyhole Logo" and the name "Open Source Initiative."
- chrisseaton 8y ago> The OSI does have trademarks for "OSI Approved Open Source License" So why don't they encourage people to use that then? Rather than telling people how to use another exiting term with a debated definition?
- sparkie 8y agoIn uncontroversial cases, it is not that people let the OSI be the arbiter, but rather, they have no need to argue with the OSI about the use of the term in those cases because their goals are aligned. The controversial cases make this clear - many people do not see the OSI as the authority on the term, and never have.
- geofft 8y agoThey're not trying to enforce it in the sense of sending the police after you for misusing it. They're just trying to establish that it has one well-accepted definition.
- sparkie 8y agoThe definition is not well-accepted. For example, why does the AGPL get a free pass but the SSPL does not? When it comes down to it, there are just a bunch of people who make arbitrary decisions about what is to be included. But what they include should not matter to you. You should not be making your decision to use software based on whether or not the OSI approved it - unless you don't have the means or expertise to decipher the specific requirements of a language and are more than happy to take the word of this organization for it. Ultimately, the OSI is a protectionist organization which is attempting to prevent a competing organization from using the term "open source" because they don't quite agree on some subtle details that an innovative licensor has chosen to attempt to gain approval of. Whether they gain approval is for the market to decide - not the OSI.
- jimktrains2 8y agoIn what way does the agpl even compare to the sspl? The agpl doesn't extend itself to any other software you're running.
- sparkie 8y agoThe AGPL has the requirement that all "derived works" are equivalently licensed. The SSPL does the same, except it has a different definition of what a derived work is, based on a more modern understanding of how software is used and distributed mainly through cloud services. People are using semantic loopholes to sidestep their AGPL requirements (the intended requirements, even if not enforcible). Whether something is a "derived work" is not black and white, but for a court to decide. It isn't at the whim of a panel of OSI judges to decide.
- 8y ago