7 ms·
Payday lenders are predatory. They want to get people locked into a cycle of debt, so that they can charge many times the original amount in interest per year.
by CydeWeys 8y ago
Payday lenders are predatory. They want to get people locked into a cycle of debt, so that they can charge many times the original amount in interest per year. I'm surprised to see anyone defending them.
- oh_sigh 8y agoPayday lenders want to lend money and get repaid. If fewer of their customers defaulted, they would probably start charging a lower interest rate.
- reallydude 8y ago> they would probably start charging a lower interest rate. I would love to see some data, because it all looks to go one way. The rates never fall, only rise.
- googlryas 8y agoI agree - you would need to look at the default rates for interest rates on their loan to mean anything. I see a bunch of independent payday lenders with similar rates. Are they a cartel and fixing their rates? Or are they in competition and all offer reasonable low rates considering the default rate of their clientele?
- Arbalest 8y agoGP starts with a fairly simple premise, the rate of default is high, so that much interest is required to make up the shortfall. Of course the rest of it is hinged solely on this premise, rather than acknowledging that the very act is taking advantage of people who can't or won't think far enough ahead to see why it is a very bad idea. It is of course the old argument that some economists use a little too regularly that all participants in the economy are rational actors.
- rayiner 8y agoThe idea that selling products and services to poor people is “taking advantage of them” in the terms reality demands is bonkers.
- king_magic 8y agoYou can’t possibly be serious w.r.t. payday lenders. I mean seriously, come on. It’s one of the most predatory types of lending that exists. They often provide loans with intentionally confusing and borderline disingenuous lending terms with the explicit goal of taking advantage of people. > The result is denying poor people access to credit. Lol, I mean, if being practically tricked into loans you can never pay off to the point that it drives entire cycles of poverty is your idea of credit, yeah, then sure, you’re right.
- doctorpangloss 8y ago> The result is denying poor people access to credit. I think it sort of boils down to rayinier's wrong, or at least hopelessly unsophisticated, understanding of credit. When you don't pay your landlord on time, you definitely enter a debt relationship with your landlord. That's credit in every sense but financial. Payday loan companies securitized a form of credit that had low effective "interest" (e.g., late payment penalties) and converted it into something with high interest. Yes, nobody wants to be evicted. But surely, in a strictly rational economic sense, landlords don't want vacant properties either. It's not so obvious what is the "efficient rate," as rayinier says, because based on eviction rates for late payments of rents, it's probably not that high. Foreclosing on people's homes, of course, was a huge disaster and the source of an incredible amount of national economic and emotional misery. So again, just within an economic positivist framework, it's not at all as simple to arrive at "efficient" rates as rayinier assumes. I'm not sure if payday loan companies, which charge a higher interest rate to essentially victimize the same population at an industrial scale, is an economic positive, you know? I wish he would just admit that while some human beings will sometimes be landlords, and therefore deserve some protections, no normal person will literally ever be a payday loan lender, so it seems fit that we ought to use a credit system (late rental payments) that people can imagine justice inside of rather than an usurious credit system nobody will ever be on the right side of.
- calvinmorrison 8y agoHonestly, they're providing a service and there are customers. Walter block who is a noted austrian-school economist did a fun set of books called "Defending the Undefendable" where he runs through thought experiments about Slumlords, Payday Lenders, Pimps, etc. I'm not asking you to agree with him, or start defending pimps but reading through some of those is a fun way to get a different take on things. Book is available in print but also below for free from Mises: https://mises-media.s3.amazonaws.com/Defending_the_Undefendable_2018.pdf https://mises-media.s3.amazonaws.com/Defending_the_Undefenda...
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoThe service is masked in high fees that do not apply to your principle payments. They are borderline fraud. Had try been totally transparent then we wouldn’t need to regulate the industry as much. The fact that anyone can defend a payday lending operation knowing how it works is puzzling. I don’t know what your motivations are or of those who say nice things on behalf these “businesses” but they are certainly not in the interests of the consumer.
- calvinmorrison 8y agoI guess you didn't actually read my comment. I'm gonna blow your mind with this: people have differing opinions on things and that you have to immediately question my 'motivations' or assume i'm some sort of 'paid actor' is the kind of ad hominem attacks I'm so used to seeing on HN. Payday lending offers a very specific type of service. Extreme short term loans. Like all loans, there is risk associated. Unlike other loans traditional payment plans do not really apply. Interest rates will be different. However, with the market operating appropriately, people will move towards the better options. This might include, better service, better interest rates, better contractual agreements, who knows. It's the free market. I wasn't even defending it. I was pointing to an economist who is a noted hard libertarian type who did defend it, in the hopes that someone might read it and think to themselves - for a fat second - "wow some people do not see the world the way I do", you have utterly failed that test.
- Bud 8y ago
- rayiner 8y agoAnd Facebook and Google want to get you locked in a cycle of mindless browsing and ad consumption. The difference is that Facebook and Google operate in markets with high barriers to entry resulting in fat profit margins. Payday lenders, by contrast, operate in a market with immense amounts of competition. There’s one on every block in most places. Payday lenders don’t lock people in cycles of debt. What looks people in cycles of debt is that their income levels are marginal so any unexpected event can totally derail them. I have a paid off car. When I got into a fender bender, I needed to pay $2,500 out of pocket to fix it because I don’t carry insurance for damage to my own vehicle. If I was poor, what would I do? I can go to a payday lender, who has to charge high fees because poor people are high risk. I’m caught in a cycle of debt—because I couldn’t afford that expense to begin with. But at least I can get around. If you take away that option, I don’t get my car fixed and lose my job. That’s the alternative.
- Angostura 8y ago> If you take away that option, I don’t get my car fixed and lose my job. That’s the alternative. Except the rule that is being killed is the one that told lenders they needed to check to ensure that the borrower would be able to pay the loan back. In your case, with your car and your job, you would pass this test. And if you couldn’t then lending the money would put you in a worse position than immediate unemployment
- rayiner 8y ago> And if you couldn’t then lending the money would put you in a worse position than immediate unemployment I’m glad some upper middle class attorney or policy wonk at CFPB gets to make the decision that it’s better for me to lose my job than to deal with debt I can’t repay!
- Angostura 8y agoI sense a touch of sarcasm, but yes it's a good idea to have a set of transparent, set rules that can be used to decide whether you will be able to repay, or whether you are set to enter into an ever increasing debt-spiral with a predatory company.
- tryptophan 8y ago>so that they can charge many times the original amount in interest per year. These are short term (till the next payday) loans. Thats like saying a hotel room costs 36.5k/yr. News websites posting crazy 400% apr numbers are being deliberately misleading. When in reality its more like you pay a 20% fee to get money now and repay it next payday in 2 weeks.
- hnmullany 8y agoBut a hotel does cost $36,500 a year if you stay in it that much and that's closer to what a substantial percentage of pay day borrowers actually end up doing: >> Payday loans are often thought of as “two-week” loans, which aligns with the data’s median term >> of 14 days. However, since the terms of these loans are often tied to the borrower’s pay cycle, >> which can vary by employer and source of income, the average loan length is 18.3 days. >> And while payday loans are marketed as short-term solutions — get cash now, pay it back in two >> >> weeks — the CFPB found that over the course of 12 months, more than one-third of borrowers will take >> out between 11 and 19 payday loans. Fourteen percent of borrowers will take out 20 or more payday >> loans within this same time period. >> It’s on these borrowers that payday lenders make the most money. According to the CFPB, 76% of >> lenders’ fees come from borrowers taking out at least 11 loans in a year. from: https://consumerist.com/2013/04/26/the-average-payday-loan-borrower-spends-more-than-half-the-year-in-debt-to-lender/ https://consumerist.com/2013/04/26/the-average-payday-loan-b...
- thaumaturgy 8y ago> Payday lenders have low losses and high profits (34%+ return on investment) > A payday lender would have to work hard to lose money, even though borrowers are generally low-income and have weak credit histories. Holding a "live" check as security gives a lender strong collateral and leverage over a borrower who, when faced with the threat of criminal prosecution and penalty fees, will keep paying renewal fees every two weeks when they cannot afford to repay the loan in full and walk away. With these renewals (or loan flips), they are never paying down the principal owed. In North Carolina in 2000, for example, only 6% of payday checks were returned for insufficient funds (NSF) and lenders recovered about 69% of the value on these. They also collected $2 million in NSF fees. > In comparison, the credit card default rate, like the payday default rate, is also approximately 6% -- but the interest rate on a credit card rarely exceeds 29% (as opposed to payday loans that routinely charge 400% APR or more). Personal loans and car loans have default rates of around 2%, with APRs between 5 and 15%. Compared to other forms of credit, the exorbitantly high APR charged on payday loans is drastically out of proportion with the relatively normal risk involved in making those loans. https://www.responsiblelending.org/research-publication/fact-v-fiction-truth-about-payday-lending-industry-claims#five https://www.responsiblelending.org/research-publication/fact... The whole page is worth reading.
- rayiner 8y agoThat page has no citation for the 34% figure.
- thaumaturgy 8y agoThe number appears to come from a report titled "Survey of non-bank financial institutions: Final report prepared for U.S. Department of the Treasury", authored by an outfit called Dove Consulting, back around 2000 or thereabouts. See also p. 10 of http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.195.8298&rep=rep1&type=pdf http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.195... [pdf]
- kortilla 8y agoSo are banks, credit card companies, etc. Their dream is always the customer making minimum payments and maybe some late payments for fees. Look at the dump that is Wells Fargo and the their precious behavior with deposit/withdrawal ordering in daily reconciliation to screw people into overdraft fees. Drawing the line at payday lenders seems super arbitrary.
- dlp211 8y agoThe CFPB has gone after Wells Fargo and other banks for exactly that reason.
- CydeWeys 8y agoNobody here is drawing that line. Almost anyone who's in favor of going after predatory payday lenders will also be in favor of going after the predatory practices of big banks, like transaction ordering to maximize overdraft fees. The CFPB can and should fix all of this.
- pps43 8y agoCustomers making only the minimum payments, and especially customers who are occasionally delinquent are very risky. Those are some of the strongest independent variables in behavior credit scores. Credit card companies are not making much money from those customers. Banking dream is lending money to people who don't need it.