4 ms·
Maybe I'm missing something; it mentioned it was using organs from executed prisoners. Is that a bad thing? Again, I feel like I missed a part of this article
by tombert 8y ago
Maybe I'm missing something; it mentioned it was using organs from executed prisoners. Is that a bad thing?
Again, I feel like I missed a part of this article, so I'm genuinely confused.
EDIT: I was under the (erroneous) impression that these people were being executed for other crimes, like murder or rape or something. I didn't realize people were being executed on demand. That's terrifying.
- quotha 8y agoDude, you need to consent to having your organs donated.
- xiii1408 8y agoYes, that's a bad thing. The Chinese state has a documented history of executing people on demand in order to harvest their organs: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organ_harvesting_from_Falun_Gong_practitioners_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organ_harvesting_from_Falun_Go.... Even if you were going to be executed anyway, you obviously have a right to determine what happens to your organs, particularly in cultures like China's, where it's seen as very important that the body remain whole.
- x220 8y agoHey do you mind if I kill you and take your organs? Is that a bad thing?
- tombert 8y agoI was (mistakenly) assuming that the people were convicted of other crimes (like murder or something), and then the organs were being used post-execution.
- shaki-dora 8y agoWell... There probably was, at some point, some person giving an impression of a judge worthy of a b-movie extra who signed something titled "Death Sentence" and continuing with "Lorem ipsum...". In other words: It doesn't much matter if these people were convicted or not when the judicial system making those decisions is deeply flawed. And, of course, there are the additional problems of the death penalty itself being rather anachronistic, and even people on death row remaining humans and retaining fundamental right to dignity, which would stand in the way of using them as spare part repositories against their own will. So there's like eight layers of injustice until you can get a liver from a Chinese.
- grownseed 8y agoMorality of the death sentence aside, I think the underlying issue here is that this may also be a driver for killing people in the first place. For example, the presence of "re-education" camps was brought up again recently, in particular relating to Uighur muslims and more generally political and ideological dissidents, whereby the camps have grown considerably (despite contradicting statements on the international scene) and people seem to get "re-educated" indefinitely.
- noname120 8y agoAllowing organ harvesting creates an incentive for executing prisoners.