3 ms·
> Reminds me of the time someone tried to legislate pi=3 There's absolutely no way to give police a back door into encryption without giving criminals the same
by tzs 8y ago
> Reminds me of the time someone tried to legislate pi=3 There's absolutely no way to give police a back door into encryption without giving criminals the same back door.
Most secure N party communication systems can be made to be secure N+1 party communication systems. If that +1 is the police, then arguably you have in fact given police a back door without giving criminals the same back door.
Criminals who want in would have to do so the same way they would before the back door--compromise one of the parties to the communication--except now there are N+1 parties to try and compromise instead of N so the attack surface is larger. How much this lowers security depends largely on the competence of the +1 party.
The popular model of a back door seems to be some wide open spying interface protected only by running on an undocumented port or something like that, and that all the bad guys have to do is get a copy of one client, reverse engineer it to find the access info, and then they are in.
For some reason, people tend to overlook that a back door is really just another communication channel, and the mechanisms modern cryptography provides for securing communication channels apply to back doors as much as they do to any other channel.
- LoSboccacc 8y ago> you have in fact given police a back door without giving criminals the same back door As long as one corrupt cop exists on the access pool the premise doesn't hold up.
- mattnewton 8y agoThere exist some secure schemes where keys are not exchanged, and those would be effectively outlawed. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-pass_protocol https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-pass_protocol Nevermind that increasing the parties being attacked almost always makes the job easier not harder. See the TSA master key debacle for an example of how adding a third party master weakened the security and allowed statistical analysis to break the lock.