5 ms·
I'd be curious to hear, from someone who's actually read the book, what arguments it makes to show receptionist is a bullshit job? To me it seems like a pretty
by michaelt 8y ago
I'd be curious to hear, from someone who's actually read the book, what arguments it makes to show receptionist is a bullshit job?
To me it seems like a pretty useful job in a large organisation.
- diego 8y agoCurious why do you think it's useful. What do you imagine happens in large organizations without full-time receptionists?
- pnutjam 8y agoWasting the time of people with other duties.
- oconnore 8y agoTotal chaos. Even when we were 20 people in an office folks coming in for interviews or to fix the WiFi/Coffee machine/plumbing would either be totally lost, or the person sitting near the door would be significantly burdened with constant distraction and less able to perform their primary function. Furthermore no one would set up those maintenance tasks because they’re focused on the product not on making sure the office is functioning properly.
- bilbo0s 8y ago>Furthermore no one would set up those maintenance tasks because they’re focused on the product not on making sure the office is functioning properly.... Hmm. Not trying to get in between you guys arguing, but I'm just throwing this out there because I thought possibly it might help. Maybe you guys aren't really disagreeing so much as using different language for different positions? Just from my point of view, it SOUNDS like what you are describing is more of an Office Manager. So maybe in some organizations Office Manager is the same as Receptionist in terms of job title? (I do hope you were PAYING that person at the level of an Office Manager though, and not a simple receptionist. That's kind of shady if you weren't, because that person was doing a great deal of work.)
- close04 8y agoImagine you work in a building of 5000+ people. What happens when dozens of interview candidates walks in? Or just dozens of visitors? Or when someone calls the company's contact phone? The actual tasks may vary depending on the company, and probably so will the job title or pay (for the very same tasks). But the job is very much real and someone will do it no matter what you call it. Some tasks may be more BS than others. But how many jobs would be considered BS in the author's vision that either they can be done by someone else or not at all because they involve addressing activities that should have been done perfect from the beginning? He's obviously aiming for controversy because controversy sells.
- jackfrodo 8y agoI've only worked in startup environments, but the office administrator just made life easier. She organized ordering catering, packages being sent and delivered, HR stuff, office errands. So not contributing to the product itself but ensuring people have the bandwidth to make the product.
- close04 8y agoA BS job is one where the tasks being performed make 0 difference to the overall situation and not doing them is hardly visible. The tasks a receptionist does are actually needed and you'd know when they are not performed. But I find other BS examples that the author used, like "airline desk staff who calm passengers whose bags don't arrive". There's no dedicated staff for this. They are simply staff who have to take the time to also do this. He sometimes mixes up "jobs" with "job tasks". Some tasks may be BS but the jobs definitely involve more than what he cherry picked as an example. Is "staff that asks you if you enjoyed the food at the restaurant" also on the list? Would he rather have airline employees just not give a shit when he has a problem? Or does he actually think airlines pay for employees that are there just to provide consolation? A "job" is the entire collection of tasks you get paid for or are expected of you by your employer. One BS portion does not make the job BS. In the same vein, is writing a list of BS jobs a BS job? He's definitely exaggerating with many examples for the purpose of making it a bit more controversial.
- lb1lf 8y agoIf our experience is anything to go by - visitors hanging around in the lobby, desperate for someone to show them the way as the automagic visitor kiosk issuing passes and notifying whoever you were about to visit that you have arrived is broken. Again. Thieves helping themselves to computers, video projectors and the like as entrance security is a joke and noone monitors the lobby anymore. Calls doing the rounds from department to department as the corporate mega-switchboard does not know anything but employees' formal title and not what they actually do - unlike the receptionist, which also manned the local switchboard. &c. You can solve most of this by throwing more money at it - but a good receptionist is IMHO money very well spent...
- michaelt 8y ago1. People resenting being sat near the door/doorbell, as they take the brunt of the interruptions. 2. Important deliveries being sent back to the parcel depot because the door wasn't answered 3. Parcels sometimes going missing, with the parcel company claiming they were delivered but no employees knowing where they are (with the resulting recriminations) 4. Guests being let in without the sign-in procedure being followed 5. Job applicants showing up saying they're here for an interview with 'Dave' and the person who lets them in not knowing who that is, where they sit, or how to contact them. These things are done much better at organisations where it's someone's job to do them.
- kolbe 8y agoDitto for goons. While goons may not be the most moral of creatures, I'm not sure it's fair to say their job is pointless and psychologically destructive.
- Mizza 8y agoI've read the book, there is a distinction between "office manager" type secretary and people who are paid to sit next to a phone which only rings twice a week. The book isn't only about the job itself, but our constant need to "look busy", even though there isn't anything to do, and most importantly, how these structures develop. He coins the phrase "corporate feudalism" as an explanation, meaning (to oversimplify) that people at the top think that other people at the top look powerful when they have lots of people below them, so they need to create a lot of jobs just to have people to be the boss of.
- kranner 8y agoThe book makes it explicit that it is talking about "receptionists and front-desk personnel at places that obviously don’t need them." The example provided is that of a Dutch publishing company at which the phone rang once a day, and the receptionist's task included keeping a "candy dish full of mints" (mints supplied by another person), winding a grandfather clock once a week, and "managing another receptionist's Avon sales." It goes on to state that the receptionist at such a place is required as a "Badge of Seriousness" even if they have nothing else to do.
- lbatx 8y agoWhile the specific examples provided don't provide immediate value, one should not overlook the value of the "Badge of Seriousness". Perhaps the receptionist job at such a firm should be looked at as less of a receptionist job and more of a sales job. If they lose out on business because they are not perceived as a serious firm, then the receptionist job provides quite a lot of value to the company, just not in the "answering phones" sort of way.
- pxndx 8y agoA hundred years ago, we didn't have many of these jobs, but people managed to live. We've automated most of the actual production jobs, but instead of having more free time, we have telemarketers, and everyone still works 40 hrs/week minimum.
- mc32 8y agoDefinitely. They tend to do the “small” things around the office, they do it in a manner people only notice when someone is not doing it. So I don’t agree designating itt a bullshit job.
- ucaetano 8y agoThe core point of the book, that 40% of jobs are bullshit, is pure bullshit, and Graeber is a know bullshitter. https://www.volkskrant.nl/columns-opinie/-er-is-een-ongelooflijke-hoeveelheid-dode-tijd-bijgekomen-~bcc09392/ https://www.volkskrant.nl/columns-opinie/-er-is-een-ongeloof... He based his assertion "on the basis of a YouGov survey among 843 Britons, in which 37 percent of the respondents said that their job 'did not make a meaningful contribution to the world', and one from HR and organizational consultant Schouten & Nelissen among 1,900 Dutch citizens, who 40 percent came out." Both surveys are very low-quality, and are contradicted by other massive surveys, which he decides to ignore because "Since then, there has been a poll that came out at 10 percent. But I'm a bit skeptical about that, because the other two polls matched."