3 ms·
> On average most woman want two children. But when a lot of them die they will get more (average of 6 around 1800). I don't believe that's true across culture
by SketchySeaBeast 8y ago
> On average most woman want two children. But when a lot of them die they will get more (average of 6 around 1800).
I don't believe that's true across cultures. Even in North America you've got social groups and organizations that are continuing to make babies like crazy.
- pasta 8y agoYes there are exceptions, but I was talking about the average. The number 2 comes from the current world wide trend. In developed countries the fertility rate tumbles down but stops at around 2. So it is believed this is the average bottom. Maybe you like this talk from Hans Rosling: https://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_religions_and_babies https://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_religions_and_babies
- urbanslug 8y agoThe commenter is talking about averages and you're talking about the tails of the graph.
- dmitriid 8y agoCultures have nothing to do with it. See Hans Rosling's talk on this [1] or see it yourself in data [2]. As soon as education, medicine, economic situation improves, you get a drop to ~2 children per woman across all cultures. [1] https://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_religions_and_babies https://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_religions_and_babies [2] https://www.google.com/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f9_&ctype=b&strail=false&nselm=s&met_x=sp_dyn_le00_in&scale_x=lin&ind_x=false&met_y=sp_dyn_tfrt_in&scale_y=lin&ind_y=false&met_s=sp_pop_totl&scale_s=lin&ind_s=false&dimp_c=country:region&ifdim=country&iconSize=0.5&uniSize=0.035 https://www.google.com/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f9_&...
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoWhile I see that there is a definite trend, if culture had nothing to do with it, why would the Israel and Faroe Islands outliers exist with many more children? And I see a ton of groups there that have the highest life expectancy and < 2 children, all Asian countries. That seems to indicate that 2 is not in fact a magic number at all.
- pixl97 8y ago>why would the Israel and Faroe Islands outliers exist with many more children? Most likely answer, religion. Successful religions grow one of two ways, and generally have encodings for both. That is they tend to have means to convert the non-religious, and secondly, and importantly in this case, have 'strong' rules on having kids. For example, in the old testament Onan was killed for 'spilling his seed' and not impregnating his dead brothers wife. That said, even in ancient times it appeared that birthrates did go down, as in Greces case, their city state succeeded. This left them open from attack and cultural take over by outside nations and ideals with higher birthrates. In the modern world we are coming to the point where human labor is not as necessary and has been supplanted by machine labor. Also machine protection, in our weapons of war. This could allow a nation/culture to shrink dramatically while still being able to defend against outside threats. If such a shrinking culture were one that 'grew' by spreading its message to other cultures it may succede to grow and shrink the entire worlds population at the same time. These ideas of disappearing utopia cultures are often touched by science fiction.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoOh, I understand all that, but the two arguments made earlier was that culture had nothing to do with it (I'd say religion is in fact part of culture), and that societies move towards having two kids, which doesn't seem to be the case, it would appear that it actually goes lower, much lower.
- dmitriid 8y ago> why would the Israel and Faroe Islands outliers exist with many more children "Many more". Israel: 3.11 (down from 4 in 1960s), Faroe Islands: 2.6 (down from 3.2 in 1970s). Compare to Niger: 7.24. And especially compare to muslim countries which just love having kids, don't they? Oh, look dropping from 8 kids per woman to around 2 for most of them (some are understandably lagging behind, like Yemen, Iraq, Gaza) > That seems to indicate that 2 is not in fact a magic number at all. I said ~2 kids, i.e. about two kids, not exactly 2 kids. There's nothing magic about this number, it's sub-replacement fertility [1]. 2.1 for developed countries, 3.4 for some developing countries. Yes, some nations will dip below 2, can't see how that disproves my words. Neither culture nor religion have anything to do with it. Give people quality of life, education, access to modern medicine, and they stop having 8 kids per woman, and quickly dip to about replacement fertility rates. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-replacement_fertility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-replacement_fertility