7 ms·
So what content creators have been denied service?
by Nursie 8y ago
So what content creators have been denied service?
- normal_man 8y agoNazis, which is apparently a problem for OP
- mschuster91 8y ago> Nazis, which is apparently a problem for OP And unfortunately for many of his fellow Americans. Unlike many Europeans, where the Nazism horror actually took place, followed with Soviet/GDR dictatorship in Eastern Europe, the American culture never has had to suffer on their own space from the real life consequences of totally unrestricted "free speech", except for a couple hundred victims of right-wing terrorism. The right to free speech actually originated in Europe ("I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it"), but European societies adjusted their view after having to endure two devastating world wars. We do have the problem that the post-WW2 position "Nazism and xenophobia is evil and its supporters should be exiled from democratic discourse and society" is slowly tearing apart, but mostly it's still supported. It's a fundamental difference in political culture and I am not sure if that can ever be solved. To my (European) view most if not all Americans see the right to "free speech" so held highly that even liberal organizations such as the ACLU keep on defending outright Nazis.
- normal_man 8y agoI think considering it an actual belief in "free speech" is giving them too much credit. It's a shield the hateful hide behind, that's all. The people screaming loudest about free speech are more than happy to shut down the rights of others.
- colpabar 8y ago> The people screaming loudest about free speech are more than happy to shut down the rights of others. Do you have an example of this?
- belltaco 8y agoCheck the heavy handed moderation on subreddits like the /r/conservative and /r/the_donald. The former has many threads that are marked "conservatives only" which auto delete any comments from anyone not tagged as conservative by mods. t_d will just delete your comments and ban you if you dare to speak out against Trump. And all this is not even counting the downvotes you get for speaking your mind in rightwing or alt right places.
- ConceptJunkie 8y agoJust try to make a comment that's even somewhat balanced in /r/politics, which is a cesspool of intolerant lefties who can't stand any disagreement or debate. Note, this is not /r/liberalpolitics, or /r/progressivepolitics, but /r/politics, and yet it is an extremely one-sided exercise in herd behavior.
- pc86 8y agoYou're 100% right and as an American I'm proud that you can't be jailed for saying something stupid. Free speech has several restrictions in the US, and anyone who says it is "totally unrestricted" is simply showing their ignorance of the actual restrictions in place. Inciting violence with your speech is a crime, and all the free speech in the world will not protect you from the backlash from private citizens and organizations. It just means the government can't lock you in a cage for saying something idiotic like "the Holocaust never happened."
- mschuster91 8y ago> Inciting violence with your speech is a crime Only if you go ahead and openly shout "kill that Jew", for example. The hidden ways to incite hatred in the masses with speech are perfectly legal, most of these even in Europe. > It just means the government can't lock you in a cage for saying something idiotic like "the Holocaust never happened." Denying the Holocaust is not just idiotic, it is an outright denial of provable facts and an immense disrespect to all the victims of the gas ovens at Auschwitz and the other KZs. In Germany, Holocaust denial is expressly forbidden by law for the latter reason.
- normal_man 8y ago> Denying the Holocaust is not just idiotic, it is an outright denial of provable facts and an immense disrespect to all the victims of the gas ovens at Auschwitz and the other KZs. Even more than that, it contributes to creating an atmosphere where it could happen again. Simply existing as a Nazi or white supremacist is a call for violence, and silencing them is justified self defense.
- ikashdfnjafh 8y agoSilencing them by what means, exactly?
- normal_man 8y agoAny
- thisisweirdok 8y agoAs soon as people start rolling out "free speech" in a conversation about business policy the entire conversation is lost. Free speech does not apply to private business. Enforcing free speech to a private business is closer to a form of government oppression than it is freedom. The United States has done a great job of brainwashing its population to think that "freedom" is universally the best thing. It's not. In many scenarios freedom actually comes from oppressing someone else (and it's no surprise that oppression is basically the cornerstone of the United States). There are just about zero websites out there that adhere to truly "free" speech because it's nearly impossible. Doubly so if you want to make a profit. Even 4chan has rules about what you can say there, believe it or not.
- mschuster91 8y ago> Even 4chan has rules about what you can say there, believe it or not. Hmm. AFAIK the only thing forbidden on 4chan is child porn because that's outlawed really really everywhere and will drive anyone away.
- thisisweirdok 8y agoYou can easily get banned for simply posting something in the wrong place.
- pedrocx486 8y agoFurry porn will also get you banned there. There's things 4Chan has strict rules against. Wild isn't it?
- gadders 8y agoI think this is an example where continental Europe differs from the UK. Although we have strong libel laws, the presumption I would hope is still closer to that put forward by JS Mill in On Liberty.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gadders 8y agoI think if it were actual Nazis - i.e. people that promote a new holocaust against anyone other than white people, etc etc then I don't think people would have a problem. Unfortunately, the term has become so devalued that "Nazi" means "Anyone that supports Trump".
- minikites 8y agoWhat do you think is the end goal of Trump's "Muslim Ban"?
- gadders 8y agoWell for starters, he hasn't banned people on the basis of their religion, but from the state they come from. I would imagine the purpose would be the same as when Obama implemented a similar ban - prevent terrorism.
- hanklazard 8y agoThere was a big controversy over Sargon being suspended, and this has prompted some other high-profile creators to leave the platform. https://podnews.net/update/patreon-controversy https://podnews.net/update/patreon-controversy
- Nursie 8y agoYeah he sounds like a racist, misogynist, homophobic arse. Not surprised they didn't want to do business with him. That's their right. --edit-- maybe I'm wrong, but the tirade I saw here sounds pretty awful - https://heavy.com/news/2018/12/patreon-sargon-of-akkad-jordan-peterson/ https://heavy.com/news/2018/12/patreon-sargon-of-akkad-jorda...
- normal_man 8y agoYou're not wrong, he's a complete piece of shit
- bluGill 8y agoTrue, but do you want to do business with a company that an enforce morality like that?
- Nursie 8y agoHonestly? Yeah I'm fine with it. Even makes me think better of them. That tirade isn't any sort of reasoned political argument, it's a hate-laden diatribe showing off some awful underlying attitudes. It's not 'enforcing morality', it's deciding not to do business with someone. That individual can do what they like, free speech is preserved, but they have no god-given right to use someone else's platform to raise money.
- sfsfsf6666 8y agoWhen I was a kid, growing up, I recall when the "moral majority" (umbrella term describing the coalition of various protestant groups), and they decided right and wrong, and had the power to a large degree, to shove that down other people's throats. Everything was closed on Sundays, dry counties (no alcohol sales), various conservative dress/grooming/self-expression conventions. They have mostly lost this influence and power, only to be replaced by something equally distasteful, your explanation not withstanding. You sound exactly like the supporters. Sure the details differ, but you've nailed down the "ends justify the means" spin, just like every other movement that wants to push their world view and morality. The kicker is the whole "it's not enforcing morality" or defending a world view schtik. It's deciding not to do business with various groups of people, under pressure from other groups of people. As a JFK democrat, and individual, I say fuck that. Good riddance.
- patorjk 8y agoLike hanklazard mentioned, Sargon was banned, but this had ripples that effected a lot of non-controversial creators. People closed their accounts due to him being banned, and I remember Tim Pool (independent journalist) complaining that he lost around half of his patreons when this happened. He was pissed.
- spangry 8y agoI think the most recent flashpoint was the deplatforming of Sargon of Akkad (Carl Benjamin). He accused white supremacists of acting like "white niggers" on a youtube livestream. In context, I think he meant this as an ironic insult. According to Patreon, this violated their rules on hate speech and they closed his account. This caused a backlash; some believed the account closure was politically motivated (Sargon is an anti-feminist, pro gamergate commentator). Some have also found it alarming that Patreon has essentially decided to police their speech in general (e.g. comments made in a youtube video, in a tweet etc.), rather than just on their own site. A number of prominent content creators have closed down their accounts in response, stating they can't trust Patreon to not deplatform them in the future for some perceived infraction. Sam Harris and Jordan Peterson are probably the most prominent of these (13th and 16th highest patron counts respectively). Here's what Sam Harris said: "As many of you know, the crowdfunding site Patreon has banned several prominent content creators from its platform. While the company insists that each was in violation of its terms of service, these recent expulsions seem more readily explained by political bias. Although I don’t share the politics of the banned members, I consider it no longer tenable to expose any part of my podcast funding to the whims of Patreon’s 'Trust and Safety' committee." And here's a NYT article on the issue: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/24/technology/patreon-hate-speech-bans.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/24/technology/patreon-hate-s...
- mcphage 8y agoNaomi Wu, who's a really cool maker out of Shenzhen: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naomi_Wu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naomi_Wu
- csa 8y agoIn case folks are wondering why, she doxxed a journalist.
- mcphage 8y agoWhich was a shitty thing to do. On the other hand, it was right after they sent a crew to China to interview her, and asked questions about her relationships & sexuality after they had explicitly agreed not to. Which is also a shitty thing to do. But guess which of them lost most of their income, and which of them ended up as an editor at the New York Times?