5 ms·
Except that he has been consistently successful over a very long period, unlike, say a Paulson who one could claim got lucky in 2008.
by cm2187 8y ago
Except that he has been consistently successful over a very long period, unlike, say a Paulson who one could claim got lucky in 2008.
- stakhanov 8y agoA thought experiment: Say I have a database with 1024 e-mail addresses. I split them in two groups. I send an e-mail to 512 of them saying "tomorrow, IBM is going to go up". To the other 512, I send an e-mail saying "tomorrow, IBM is going to go down". The next day, IBM is up, and I discard from my database the 512 people to whom I've just sent an incorrect stock tip. Then I repeat. I send an e-mail to 256 people saying "tomorrow, Microsoft is going to go up", and so forth. ...at the end of the process I have someone who I've just sent 10 correct stock tips to. -- From the point of view of that person, I have been CONSISTENTLY successful. So that doesn't really mean anything. Also: There is a saying: You only have to get rich once. It is much easier, if you come into money at one point in your life, to hold on to it, than it is to repeatedly go from zero to hero, since capital has a tendency to create more capital, and a lack of capital has a tendency to prevent you from accumulating any. I know it goes against the mindset of the American entrepreneurially-minded crowd here. But it's a thought.
- dwighttk 8y agoExcept Buffet has been emailing everyone every year since 1962; unless he has a way to pick branching timelines.
- nicoburns 8y ago> unless he has a way to pick branching timelines. Now that would be a skill that would set you up for success!
- q-base 8y agoFun thought experiment. Made me smile even though the direct relation to Buffet perhaps is a little vague. But your second saying about only getting rich once is probably closer to the truth.
- sokoloff 8y agoYou can use the "[private] tournament winner" selection process up to a certain point, but at some point far below Warren Buffett's current level, you come into the public eye. If it were akin to flipping coins, we'd almost surely have seen 16+ proto-Buffetts emerge into public consciousness only to see 15 of them blow up. Sure, there have been hedge fund failures and you could argue that Madoff was a public eye super-investor who turned out to fail, but I don't think there are enough examples of "this guy is a genius based on his track record" turning into "that guy we thought was a genius turned out to just be a lucky idiot" to suggest that all of Buffett's returns are luck.
- Sholmesy 8y agoDerren Brown did exactly this with horse racing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9R5OWh7luL4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9R5OWh7luL4
- boombust 8y agoWhile you are right, I think the parent's idea if that with a large enough sample, even if every actor is making decisions randomly, you will get actors that will just crush it. I mean Warren Buffet invested in Apple about a year ago based on the idea that they have a sticky brand and went so far as to say that iPhones were underpriced (which is just flat out wrong given how poorly they sold relative to predictions). . .and it turned out to be a terrible investment decision (so far). While I find it hard to believe that WB is all luck I think you can't dismiss that argument entirely based on his track record, no matter how successful.
- stakhanov 8y agoWell, if you take the random-chance/selection-bias as the core of a snowball and add to it the various mechanisms which mean that the game of asset management is rigged in favour of the manager, then I think there is something to this. For example, asset managers get a part of their income from a MANAGEMENT fee which is a percentage of the assets under management, that they collect regardless of whether the fund actually does well. If you get a few bets right, make a name for yourself, more people will be putting money into your funds, and it all turns into a self-fulfilling prophecy.
- hopler 8y agoBuffet also refused to invest in computer/Internet companies for many years because he knew he didn't understand them.
- smileysteve 8y agoOn Apple; on a 1 year timeline APPL beats the S&P 500 by 5%. But I don't think Buffett measures his investments on a 1 year timeline; and to be honest to your comment, he made the underpriced comment on Aug 31, 6 months ago. "I do not focus on the sales in the next quarter or the next year," he said. "I focus on the ... hundreds, hundreds, hundreds millions of people who practically live their lives by it [iPhone]." Apple does continue to boost services income, keep cash on hand, pay dividends, and do share buybacks, all with a P/E below major utility stocks -- things Buffett traditionally considers. Disclaimer. Apple Shareholder