3 ms·
> From my understanding quickly reading through the spec, it looks like HTTP/3 starts with a standard TLS handshake for key exchange, but then QUIC "crypto" fra
by tialaramex 8y ago
> From my understanding quickly reading through the spec, it looks like HTTP/3 starts with a standard TLS handshake for key exchange, but then QUIC "crypto" frames are used to carry application-level data instead of TLS frames[2]. Is this accurate?
Sort of, kinda, no? It's a "standard TLS handshake" from a cryptographic point of view, but the TLS standard specifies that all this data travels over TCP. QUIC doesn't use TCP, so for QUIC the same data is cut up differently and moved over QUIC's UDP channel. So, everything uses QUIC's frames, not just application data.
QUIC needs to solve a bunch of problems TCP already solved, plus the new problems, and chooses to do so in one place rather than split them and have an extra protocol layer. For example, "What do I do if some device duplicates a packet?" is solved in TCP, so TLS doesn't need to fix it. But QUIC needs to fix it. On the other hand, "What do I do if some middleman tries to close my connection to www.example.com?" is something TCP doesn't solve and neither does TLS but QUIC wants to, so again QUIC needs to fix it.
One reason to do all this in one place is that "it's encrypted" is often a very effective solution even when your problem isn't hostiles just idiots. For example maybe idiots drop all packets with the bytes that spell "CUNT" in them in some forlorn attempt to protect "the children". Ugh. Now nobody can mention the town of Scunthorpe! But wait, if we encrypt everything now the idiot filter will just drop an apparently random and vanishingly small proportion of packets, which we can live with. "I just randomly drop one entire packet for every 4 gigabytes transmitted" is still stupid, but now everything basically works again.