3 ms·
Having spent time reading the standards recently (and implementing some toy decoders) I've noticed a pattern in video codec designs, starting from the very firs
by userbinator 8y ago
Having spent time reading the standards recently (and implementing some toy decoders) I've noticed a pattern in video codec designs, starting from the very first one:
H.261 - simple, not much more than MJPEG with P-frames.
MPEG-1 - basically '261 with B-frames, pretty simple
MPEG-2/H.262 - MPEG-1 with more complex interlacing stuff
H.263 - no more interlacing, better low-bitrate performance
MPEG-4 - absurd complexity that no one turned out to use most of anyway (3D scenes, face animation(!?), etc.)
H.264 - back to regular video, with better I prediction
H.265 - complex again?
Of course they do get more complex over time, but it seems like a cycle that alternates between incremental-yet-significant changes and huge redesigns that don't seem quite worth it.
- richardwhiuk 8y agoH.264s intermediate frames are none trivial. Some features do get dropped, but in the majority later standards are more complex.
- ksec 8y agoYes they are all built on top of previous innovation and work. So it is a long evolution in terms of video codec. And there is H.266 coming in 2020.
- speedplane 8y agoIt is an evolution, but technological evolution doesn't necessarily follow an exponential curve. It took many years for H.264 and it looks like many more for H.266. The next version may take even longer. Innovation is slowing, and it has pretty profound effects for a variety of industrial sectors.
- nyuszika7h 8y agoPlease don't use code formatting when not necessary, it's really hard to read on mobile.
- tagrun 8y agoFilm grain synthesis of AV1 is apparently worth it: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8416572 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8416572