4 ms·
Your Child Left Behind
- anigbrowl 16y agoMeanwhile, a 2010 study of teacher-prep programs in 16 countries found a striking correlation between how well students did on international exams and how their future teachers performed on a math test. In the U.S., researchers tested nearly 3,300 teachers-to-be in 39 states. The results? Our future middle-school math teachers knew about as much math as their peers in Thailand and Oman—and nowhere near what future teachers in Taiwan and Singapore knew. This article is more than usually informative, and focuses on what's working best as well as worst (although in our case, that's sadly not saying much). Well worth the read.
- rmk 16y agoI am glad to read that the teachers' unions' claims have been more or less blown to bits by this article. Randi Weingarten & co. would have us believe that the more they are paid and the less they contribute to their own retirement (maybe zero), the better-performing the kids will be.
- danteembermage 16y agoAnd the best educated students in the entire planet according the this metric and study? White kids in D.C. who scored a 37 (compared to #2 Taiwan with a 28) in a city whose average is 1.8. http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2010/11/your-child-left-behind/66069/ http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2010/11/your-chi...
- ZeroGravitas 16y agoAfter reading this article I still have no idea what they are suggesting the problem is, or what they propose the solution is. Most of it seems based on the assumption that America should be the best at everything, and if they're not then there's some foul plot afoot and the sensationalism starts with the headline.
- yardie 16y agoYeah, the article is essentially empty of any research. "Hey Massachusetts did these things and it worked out great!" Well What did Massachusetts do? Teacher entrance exams and reshuffling money. Reshuffling money where exactly? What else did they do to improve scores? I'd also like to point out that in many other countries the state is seen as the first employer of choice. Unlike the US where Apple, Oracle, Google, and Microsoft get the best picks first and the state can choose later many countries, if you do well in school you are slotted for a teaching or gov't job with great benefits, lifetime employment, guaranteed pension, housing, etc. This might not mean much to those in the US but in Europe and most of Asia a government job is a seriously good job. This affects the US education because some of the best teachers aren't even considering teaching, not when they can pull Google money, Facebook money, or Intel money. So in that regard, the unions are right. Our free market works so well that teachers have to be paid more. Not all teachers, but certainly the best ones. This is why it's important to factor in opportunity costs when doing these samples. If the best job in China is a teacher making $50,000 than what is the equivalent in the US? $100k, $150k.
- xiongchiamiov 16y agoWell, we are of course interested in rising in the educational ranks. Don't you feel the same for your country? More importantly, > Per student, we now spend more than all but three other countries—Luxembourg, Switzerland, and Norway—on elementary and secondary education. which implies that we think we're doing a good job educating our chilluns, but are not.