You are making your point by definitional fiat, i.e. poor people are people who pay less in taxes than they take (which is not the implication of the statement

You are making your point by definitional fiat, i.e. poor people are people who pay less in taxes than they take (which is not the implication of the statement in your previous post). But it's not at all clear that most people on low incomes do that. You would have to show it.