3 ms·
“How do other countries do it?” Well it’s not an employer deciding whether it’s done so organizations just deal with it. And yes it does give effects that last
by alkonaut 8y ago
“How do other countries do it?”
Well it’s not an employer deciding whether it’s done so organizations just deal with it. And yes it does give effects that last years and disrupt organizations three layers deep. But it happens to all organizations, so it’s not a competitive disadvantage.
- chrisco255 8y agoExcept on a global scale.
- gallerdude 8y agoabsolutely, I guess, but these sorts of things (like 40 hour work week) should probably be measured relatively.
- chefkoch 8y agoIn Germany we have 12 months parental leave and it seems the country is doing quite well.
- raymond_goo 8y agogoogle target salden... we are at the verge of a collapse...
- ido 8y ago14 in fact!
- weinzierl 8y ago14 months total if both parents participate and split the time. In practice this is an incentive for men to take part because the couple gains an additional two months of paid leave. I don't have any numbers but from personal experience I'd assume that it works.
- ar0 8y agoSalaries especially for specialist jobs tend to be quite a bit lower in Germany (as is the case in Canada) than in countries like the U.S. or Switzerland which have much less generous parental leave, though. Of course, parental leave is just one variable here, but in a way this is the obvious trade-off: You can have more parental leave and lower salaries, or less parental leave and higher salaries. (The same is true for all other non-monetary benefits of a job such as job protection etc.) On a country-level, both options can work equally well. Me, personally, I would pick the "more parental leave and lower salaries", but I get that other people might feel differently. (Edit: This cuts the other way around, too, by the way. Often people in Germany will complain that people across the border in Switzerland -- or in Silicon Valley -- will earn much more, but they ignore that working days are longer, with less vacation time, less parental leave etc.)
- chrisco255 8y agoYeah it would be amazing if people could understand that there are big trade-offs with every socialistic policy. U.S. GDP per capita [1] (2018): $65,060 Germany GDP per capita [1] (2018): $49,690 The U.S. earns 22% more per capita than Germany. Imagine if the U.S. implemented policies such that our economy slowed to Germany's per capita rate. At our current GDP of $20.66 trillion, it would wipe over $4 trillion from our GDP. Seeing as the U.S. is the biggest marketplace in the world (in terms of dollars), it would have trickle down effects that would dramatically depress the world economy. [1]: https://www.imf.org/external/datamapper/NGDPDPC@WEO/USA/DEU/SWE https://www.imf.org/external/datamapper/NGDPDPC@WEO/USA/DEU/...
- corpMaverick 8y agoYes. But the long term and macro benefits also impact on a global scale.
- tomp 8y agoThat's why I'm opposed to free trade and want fair trade instead. Like, it's not wrong for e.g. EU to impose a tax on products/services produced by companies abroad that have much less strict environmental/employment laws.
- prostoalex 8y agoGet two men in the room and they will come up with three different ideas of what fair is.
- Spivak 8y agoTrade among nations with comparable or higher labor and environmental standards is free. No need for a notion of fair.
- anonuser123456 8y agoRight, but your definition of 'fair' employment laws might make poor countries unable to compete and thus stay poor. Example: poor countries can't afford the level of worker safety that rich countries can. So do you not trade with them? They then stay poor and work as subsistence farmers, something a lot worse than working in a sweatshop.
- tomp 8y agoYou’re right, that’s not good either. We need a better balance. Right now, European companies can just export production to India/China, skirting our environmental laws, making them essentially useless.
- alkonaut 8y agoAnectdotally long parental leaves correlates with high productivity. Doesn’t tell us which way the causation points but there are factors like a large fraction of women in the workforce that pull in the right direction on a national level but don’t help individual companies. I’d support it even if the causation is only the other way - i.e. it’s a reform people in rich productive countries choose to spend on.
- falcolas 8y agoAt a global scale, the nation that respects the fewest human rights will win when it comes to low cost labor. My opinion is that we should never ascribe to be (or be competitive with) that nation, however.
- rb808 8y agoIn reality its not that simple. Its often extra difficult for 30-35 year old women to find new jobs as employers are wary. Its also more difficult for women to return to work after taking longer off. Discrimination lawsuits are more common in Europe from what I've seen.
- alkonaut 8y agoThat’s why it’s parental leave not maternal leave. Women are usually away longer but it’s not uncommon in countries with long parental leaves to have some part (e.g 1/3) reserved for each parent. Employers aren’t wary if a 30 year old man is as likely to leave for 6 months as a woman is to leave for 12. Orgs don’t avoid hiring all 30year olds out of fear they might become parents. Other reforms such as free/subsidized daycare can be needed if you want to help parents return to work after the kid is 1-2 years.
- wolfgke 8y ago> Employers aren’t wary if a 30 year old man is as likely to leave for 6 months as a woman is to leave for 12. Orgs don’t avoid hiring all 30year olds out of fear they might become parents. If you don't know who will leave, just do some statistics. Currently, it is more women. If fashion changes, it might be that an age group that has not completed family planning will simply be discriminated against.
- alkonaut 8y agoSome stats from where I am: 30% of parental leave days are used by men (was 10% in mid 90s). A clear majority of dads do go on some leave, and of course almost all women do. Of 480 days to share between parents 90 days are reserved for each, meaning it’s a typical minimum for the father to do at least the 90. A more normal division is 12 months for the mother and 4-5 for the father. Of course the stats say women leave more days. But importantly men take enough leave that it’s starting to not make that much difference e.g to an employer.