6 ms·
Reddit is still a haven for the far-right. It really leaves a bad taste in my mouth that they are tolerated there.
by LeoPanthera 8y ago
Reddit is still a haven for the far-right. It really leaves a bad taste in my mouth that they are tolerated there.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoWhile this may be true, Reddit's "free speech" ethos has been part of its DNA from day 1. Reddit has also gone a long way to getting rid of the most egregious content (I mean, jailbait???) What would you suggest the alternative is? I think the real problem is that society is coming to terms with the fact that anonymous free speech isn't all it's cracked up to be.
- lostlogin 8y ago> What would you suggest the alternative is? Does there need to be one? This site seems to manage to avoid it. Quite how you get into the situation reddit did is mystifying to me. I completely agree that anonymous free speech is not the ideal it sounds.
- figgis 8y ago> This site seems to manage to avoid it. If we are going to be reasonable a better comparison would be comparing this site to a single heavily moderated subreddit. As an extreme you have subreddits like https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/ if you look into the comments you will see a lot of "[ Removed ]" threads. https://i.imgur.com/Q7mXkPd.png https://i.imgur.com/Q7mXkPd.png Other subreddits are purposefully not moderated as heavily. It's entirely up to whoever runs it to moderate how they see fit.
- Rebelgecko 8y agoI don't think it's accurate to say that reddit has a free speech ethos. Maybe "free speech up until the point where it causes problems with revenue". For example, a year or so ago Reddit overhauled its rules to ban subreddits that were used to facilitate exchanging or gifting drugs (including alcohol and tobacco). However that rule has an exemption saying that advertisements for alcohol, tobacco, and narcotics are still OK. So /r/beertrade gets banned, but reddit will still happily show me ads for some winery founded by MIT grads. Reddit will also ban subreddits for hosting content that some people may think is "bad", but definitely not illegal. Not that I miss /r/shoplifting, but the discussion itself wasn't illegal. They also banned legal things like firearm schematics and r/brassswap
- vvillena 8y agoFar-right communities would be alright if they could be hate-free. They usually have a hard time doing that.
- hopler 8y agoJailbait was tacky and creepy, but in line with what you have on Instagram. It pales in comparison to the virulent racism and sexism that still pervades the site (not confined to any subreddit)
- 2019ideas 8y agoyou mean alt right. Alt right is the racism and tariff producing political force. I would hope you don't have a bad taste from right leaning economics. Not even China can deny the power of Free Markets.
- iamaelephant 8y agoFree market economics is not a "far right" concept.
- 2019ideas 8y agoI am relieved to hear people saying that.
- hopler 8y agoChina is not a free market. It is a state controlled market.
- ddingus 8y agoThe way to deal is not to push them off the net. They will cry foul and get plenty of attention. A while back, a far right sub got closed. People were kind of lost as always happens when moderators take a sub private. Others, and this happened during the heay of the 2016 election, offered up a space. A thread on a definitely not far right sub. Was, "have a beer, tell us about it" essentially. No judgement, just a place to talk past frustration. The chatter that night was interesting. Relations were permenantly improved. Some of the "far" was also rolled off. (I was there, ran that little experiment and followed users and discussion for a time afterword.) Aaron was passionate about this effect. Reddit, in general, used to be. When people talk broadly, things improve. When they get contained, things amplify. Reddit sees people with interests, things to say. Others, including some moderators at Reddit, sees groups of people. That clash is not talked about as much as it should be. Humanizing others different from us is something Reddit has done well. When it is done, the state of conflict improves. Reddit has also contained discussion, and amplified the toxic too. Ugly stuff. We all run the same basic way, and we all have more in common than we often recognize, or admit. One other thing: A very toxic shitpost sub got to hating on a community I moderated. Two of us decided to make some friends. For a month, we would rate their toxicity, employ good humor, laugh with, etc... Amazingly, this worked far better than we expected. Soon, there were people in that toxic mess rooting for us, and it became increasingly difficult for the sub to be toxic and believe it had impact. As the tipping point approached, we got banned, and the shitposts to follow fell flat. Everyone saw how ugly it was and our humor was missed. They quit after that. The friends remained, some left the toxic haven. Now, there are people like you and me that have the same bad taste for "far lefties", and in general, "those other people." What we community managers, app builders, data scientists should be doing is finding ways to exploit the effects I put here. And we should be making tools to foster better communication. Those tools are software, and giving people options, making them aware of their own agency in dialog. The former has only limited success as many communities will show. Blocks, bans, other things... When combined with empowering people to take charge of their interactions, weigh what others say, it is a whole new game. I have applied these to communities who end up very troll resistant and able to communicate across broad swaths of humanity. Righteous indignation is not the only way to respond to toxic speech. In fact, it is often the very worst, yet the domimant exchange is indignation, largely for the often set expectations encouraging it. Some rando says something toxic and when weighted, it is laughable, pathetic. It for sure is not meaningful. Trolling works on righteous indignation. Free hugs, humor, empathy, and more all snuff it out. The same goes for very different worldviews. Make some friends, have a common human basis and those differences begin to melt. Frankly, I see 3 billion being used to sell shit, get user data. Shame that some of it is very unlikely to be used to improve communications and add some real value along the way. Edit: Reddit is an amazing playform to run the social dynamics experiments. Lots to be learned there for those who go looking.
- tootahe45 8y agoAlmost everything on Reddit is far-left, or at least anti-Trump. Every front-page sub (e.g. r/pics, which you'd think would be completely non-political) gets bombarded with this spam. You have to actually go looking to find right-wing content, letalone "far-right" content which I haven't come across unless you deem memes to be far-right. Hell, the fact they won't change r/politics to a more accurate name and remove it from the front page shows you exactly who Reddit caters to.
- rootusrootus 8y agoOver 60% of the voting population disagrees with Trump, so by definition that position is not far-anything, it is mainstream.
- TheRealDunkirk 8y agoIt is also still a haven for the far-left. Does that leave a bad taste in your mouth too?
- opportune 8y agoyeah the people who want to redistribute money are equally as scary as the ones who are actively racist
- qgsrw3fd 8y agoIf your comment is not sarcastic, you can go and ask in Eastern Europe if the people who want to "redistribute money" are scary or not.
- vvillena 8y agoPlease, don't equate taxes to a complete nationalization of nearly all industries plus a ban on all monetary transactions save a few whitelisted types. It's an absurd comparison that does nothing to further the current discussion.
- qgsrw3fd 8y agoI didn't actually. The guy up there was talking about "far left" which I understand as Communism, not simply "taxes". If there's something absurd, it is saying that far left is simply "taxes".
- LeoPanthera 8y agoWhile I question whether this is true, if it is, yes, it does. Violent extremism, or incitement of violent extremism, of any form, should not be tolerated.
- rootusrootus 8y agoDoes advocating for single-payer healthcare, free community college, marriage equality, pro-choice, and higher tax rates for wealthy individuals constitute 'far left'? Serious question. I have in mind what I would think of as far left, but I don't see those folks are particularly well represented in the United States.