> it really should be graded based on how much you improve over time rather than whether you can reach certain goal Agreed. After my first year of regular P.E.

> it really should be graded based on how much you improve over time rather than whether you can reach certain goal Agreed. After my first year of regular P.E. I signed up for a class focused entirely on strength and fitness. No team sports. Two days on the track, three days in the weight room. Physically it was a far more demanding class, but it was taught by a far more reasonable teacher. Despite being among the slowest when it came to running the mile, I still received an A for showing effort and improvement.