3 ms·
Because people start off with nothing essentially. And the statement on abundance is the same exact fallacy as Marx. Although to be fair it predated him in far
by Nasrudith 8y ago
Because people start off with nothing essentially. And the statement on abundance is the same exact fallacy as Marx. Although to be fair it predated him in far /worse/ forms like many "thinkers" in Ancient Greece thinking conquest was the only way to obtain more wealth. They thought that if someone managed to conquer and enslave the entire world they wouldn't build any more wealth over time. Medieval economic philosophy had a denialism that merchants could be generating value without fraud because they presumed universal values of good. While exploitation may be real presuming that management and capital contribute nothing is just plain not anchored in reality.
Hunter gatherers have little social stratification but no real wealth inequality because they are limited to what they can carry personally and cooperative health is what keeps them alive. It takes a /lot/ of skill and knowledge to live on one's own in the wilderness without advanced tools like say a steel knife.
Productivity is what creates wealth in a meaningful sense. It can improve and boost living standards per person without a specialized pyramid scheme of labor. Proof? The fact that industrialized societies aren't over 90% farmers and haven't starved to death!
While raw inputs may come from land processing it is where the bulk of value actually comes from. If I gave you a claim to all of the gold in Antarctica it would be of very little value because of the extraction expenses.
- claudiawerner 8y ago>Because people start off with nothing essentially. This is disputed by figures as diverse as Aristotle, Spinoza, Hegel and Rousseau. It is not fact at least as presented here without discussion. >While exploitation may be real presuming that management and capital contribute nothing is just plain not anchored in reality. The theory of exploitation in Marx or post-Marx (even without the LTV) does not depend on the assumption that capitalists cannot add value. I'd suggest looking at the work of John Roemer and his work on PECP and CECP. >It can improve and boost living standards per person without a specialized pyramid scheme of labor. Was this ever cast in doubt? I'd also caution the application of a historical example to the society of today, since the applicability of the principle has not been proven. >While raw inputs may come from land processing it is where the bulk of value actually comes from. This is textbook Marx.
- ozzyman700 8y ago"Because people start off with nothing essentially" I do not believe this. In a world without private property, everyone is entitled to the world's land. Everyone has everything available to them. People survive off the land. Eventually these people don't want to just survive, so they begin to do a single thing all day (hunting, gathering, eventually farming) They trade the output of their labor (their wages of berries, food) for other peoples output. The introduction of private property allows for some people to collect rent on productivity, without actually being productive. Private property is a tax on productivity and rent will always consume any excess production value. Progress drives poverty, as well as any inequality in wealth only increasing as time goes on in a positive feedback loop. "While exploitation may be real presuming that management and capital contribute nothing is just plain not anchored in reality." I don't believe this either. I believe any rent-seeking is adverse to progress towards eliminating poverty. I see it as a failure of society to allow for the upper class to enjoy greater pleasures as time goes on at the expense of those born poor. We are all guests on a floating spaceship rocketing through space. The idea of inheritance has no place in a free market in my opinion, it should be taxed as income for the recipient. Inheritance is the vessel through which wage equality is growing larger, in my opinion.