3 ms·
The problem with articles like this is that that present it as being a de facto justification for "I don't believe the dr". It's a variation of survivor bias -
by olliej 8y ago
The problem with articles like this is that that present it as being a de facto justification for "I don't believe the dr".
It's a variation of survivor bias - you don't see articles "s/he thought the dr was wrong! But the Dr was right!" because they obviously don't produce headlines.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- taneq 8y agoYeah, survivor bias was the first thing that leapt to my mind when she mentioned the 'zebra effect'. The doc is 100% correct in saying that this patient almost certainly doesn't have the super rare disease (although maybe he should have revisited that heuristic when the other, more likely diagnoses fell through). He was right the other 9 times he told people their odd-sounding symptoms were just a common disease presenting oddly... but people don't write news articles about horses.
- sterlind 8y agoSpeaking as an officially-diagnosed zebra (Ehlers-Danlos syndrome), it took a year of doctor searching until I found a specialist who knew what to look for.. and it started with someone in a powerchair I met at a party remarking that my skin felt velvety like his. Many doctors are bad at conditional probability. [0] 2% of the healthy population is hypermobile, and hEDS is ~1:5000. But P(hEDS|atrophic scars, spontaneous dislocations, 7/9 Beighton score, paralysis attacks) is much higher. There's a weird stigma against zebras seeking diagnoses because you almost have to do your own research to be diagnosed properly. 0. https://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/04/25/chances-are/ https://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/04/25/chances-are...
- taneq 8y agoYeah, I remember reading something about that in some introductory Bayesian statistics article. They asked a whole bunch of doctors the P(cancer | positive screening test) question and their answers were way off. Which is fair because it's pretty unintuitive, but also not good because they're using that intuition to make life-and-death decisions. By weird coincidence, I think one of my friends was recently diagnosed with EDS after a long, long search to find out what was actually going on with her.
- cm2187 8y agoPlus if I read it correctly she asked for a second opinion at the request of the first dr. It is common in medecine for a doctor to be defeated or surprised by the symptoms and to refer the patient to a another specialist who has more experience with a particular type of disease.