3 ms·
When Ted Turned tried “democratizing” old classic B&W movies he was made fun of, a lot, not by the audience/viewers, but by the professional critics who claimed
by mc32 8y ago
When Ted Turned tried “democratizing” old classic B&W movies he was made fun of, a lot, not by the audience/viewers, but by the professional critics who claimed he was ruining the intrinsic art of those movies, the implication was he was degenerating them.
Sure, the colors were not quite right (I think they improved them after initial missteps), but he was a man ahead of his time with his vision in that regard. Few would bat an eye today.
- chasing 8y ago80s colorized movies looked pretty terrible. That was at least half the problem. I’d say we’re actually more open to black and white media these days. It doesn’t have the ‘stink of the old’ that it had in the couple of decades after color TVs first became cheap. Now it’s viewed more as a stylistic choice and not simply an imperfection to be fixed.
- mc32 8y ago>80s colorized movies looked pretty terrible. They have their issues, for sure, but viewers, as I understand it, weren't the complainers, it was mostly the professional critics and artsy types who derided them. Joe and Jill Public cared little, as far as I understand it. They complained about "artistic intent" and respecting it, etc., etc.
- rangibaby 8y agoBlack and white movies should stay black and white. George Lucas shouldn’t have messed with Star Wars. Film movies should have film grain. You shouldn’t use a computer to remove grain and make Arnold look like a Madame Tussaud’s sculpture. You shouldn’t crop 4:3 sources to 16:9 because you think people prefer losing some image to black bars. Stop tinkering with shit to “improve” it. I wouldn’t care, but I do care because it means I have to spend my time taking hours on the internet to find an obscure VHS rip of a version that has not been debauched by digital Dicks.
- bscphil 8y agoI mean, I agree with you, but I don't think GP overstated at all just how much the average consumer doesn't care about this stuff. Most of us know people who prefer to have their TV stretch (not just crop) the image from its original aspect ratio to 16:9. I know people who refuse to watch black and white films because they're "boring". Not because of the subject matter, but because they're black and white.