3 ms·
> Congestion pricing works in the same way that hiring someone to throw bricks off > an overpass into car windshields during rush hour would work. That is a
by mcv 8y ago
> Congestion pricing works in the same way that hiring someone to throw bricks off
> an overpass into car windshields during rush hour would work.
That is a horrible comparison. Horrible in two different ways.
> The first is that it can only really improve one thing -- traffic during peak
> times -- which only really matters to the people who are still driving at those
> times, who then have the benefit offset by the cost of the congestion charge.
It improves general mobility. Less traffic jams, and money to invest in alternatives. People can still drive during peak times but reduce the cost and congestion by carpooling. People can take other forms of transport, and people can drive at a different time. The end result is that everybody still gets to where they need to be, but without getting stuck in traffic for an hour.
I don't disagree with your alternatives, but they have already been tried and haven't solved the problem. Maybe more money is needed to do it better? Congestion pricing can provide that. But it also helps to encourage people a bit more. A lot of people take the car because it's what they're used to, and they simply hope traffic won't be too bad. But with a little push, they'll be a bit more likely to try public transport. And with more people using it, there will also be more demand to improve it.
Living closer to work/working closer to home would of course be best, but again, it's not something that has worked so far. Some people don't have that luxury, and some people simply don't want to for other reasons.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Less traffic jams, and money to invest in alternatives. Assuming the money goes to alternatives, which it typically doesn't, and moreover that there isn't a less regressive way to generate the same money, such as sales or income tax. > People can still drive during peak times but reduce the cost and congestion by carpooling. People can take other forms of transport, and people can drive at a different time. The end result is that everybody still gets to where they need to be, but without getting stuck in traffic for an hour. They can already do any of those things, if they were viable for them. You can save hundreds of dollars a year in fuel and vehicle maintenance by carpooling, and then everyone but the driver can read or text or work from the passenger's seat. The people who are driving alone during rush hour are the people for which that isn't an efficient option -- they already had significant incentives to do it regardless, and it wasn't enough. > I don't disagree with your alternatives, but they have already been tried and haven't solved the problem. They haven't solved the problem because they haven't actually been tried. Most of them aren't even a matter of money, they're a matter of eliminating restrictive zoning rules and minimum parking requirements. > A lot of people take the car because it's what they're used to, and they simply hope traffic won't be too bad. But with a little push, they'll be a bit more likely to try public transport. Traffic during rush hour is commuters. Commuters know exactly how the traffic is because they're in it every day, and none of them want to be. And if it was a matter of a little push then the congestion charges wouldn't have to be as high to change behavior. They have to be because sitting in traffic is already terrible and the people doing it are doing it for lack of better options. Provide the options and enough of them will stop doing it.
- mcv 8y ago> Assuming the money goes to alternatives, which it typically doesn't, That's a different issue. But the money is there and it could and should be used in a productive manner. > and moreover that there isn't a less regressive way to generate the same money, > such as sales or income tax. Sales and income tax don't discourage traffic jams. But if you want, sure you could send the income from congestion pricing to something else and use other taxes to fund alternatives. > They can already do any of those things, if they were viable for them. You can > save hundreds of dollars a year in fuel and vehicle maintenance by carpooling, > and then everyone but the driver can read or text or work from the passenger's > seat. They can, but they don't. Everybody hopes someone else will be the first to do that so they don't have to. With a bit of push, you can encourage more people to do this and make life a lot easier for everybody. > They haven't solved the problem because they haven't actually been tried. Yes, they have been tried. There's a good reason why experts say that congestion pricing seems to be the only thing that works. With every other approach, traffic grows to fill the available space until you get massive traffic jams. The US isn't the only country with this problem; many countries have it. Netherland has tried for years to solve it without congestion pricing by building more and wider roads, mass transit, zoning and whatever, and it's not working. Meanwhile, countries that have tried congestion pricing see it working. Congestion pricing is probably not a silver bullet that magically solves everything, but it might well be a vital ingredient to get people to actually use the alternatives. The options are there, but too many people just aren't using them. Why they don't is a good question, but from the available evidence, it appears that congestion pricing provides the necessary push.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> That's a different issue. But the money is there and it could and should be used in a productive manner. The point is that it's not free money. You don't get to spend resources without paying for them. The money comes from someone and that has a cost. And where they come from is worse than where most other types of taxes come from, because it's an incredibly regressive form of taxation. > Sales and income tax don't discourage traffic jams. They also don't come disproportionately from working class people. And there are better ways to discourage traffic jams. > But if you want, sure you could send the income from congestion pricing to something else and use other taxes to fund alternatives. There is no such thing as directing specific tax money to a specific purpose. That's just an accounting dodge politicians use to lie to people. Money is fungible. The people paying don't pay a different amount and the people getting paid don't get paid a different amount. What you can do is fund mass transit improvements from sales or income tax and not have congestion charges at all, which a significantly less regressive way to fund mass transit improvements. > They can, but they don't. Many of them do. More of them would if we had higher density housing and it was easier to find close neighbors who work in the same area, or just take the train to work. > Yes, they have been tried. There's a good reason why experts say that congestion pricing seems to be the only thing that works. With every other approach, traffic grows to fill the available space until you get massive traffic jams. China built a huge number of highways as a jobs program. They didn't suddenly fill up with traffic. Los Angeles has worse traffic than New York City, even though there are more people in New York (both the cities themselves and the surrounding metro areas). Because New York has double the population density, and better mass transit. If population and density always caused traffic then how is New York better than Los Angeles? And that's with New York shooting itself in the foot like this: http://furmancenter.org/research/publication/are http://furmancenter.org/research/publication/are You're not allowed to build housing with no parking even when it's next to a subway station. So housing in the city costs more because of the expense, causing more people to live outside the city and have to commute in. Meanwhile the people who do live there have mandatory parking spaces, encouraging them to own cars even when they live next to the subway. New York also has density limits that would prohibit many of the existing buildings from being constructed today. Meanwhile they still charge money for mass transit -- not a lot, but enough to deter people for no good reason, and then a huge chunk of the money collected gets wasted on the infrastructure needed to collect and enforce the fees. This isn't what having tried looks like. > The US isn't the only country with this problem; many countries have it. Netherland has tried for years to solve it without congestion pricing by building more and wider roads, mass transit, zoning and whatever, and it's not working. There are a hundred ways to do it wrong. That doesn't mean it's impossible to do it right. > Meanwhile, countries that have tried congestion pricing see it working. It's only working if reducing congestion is the only criteria and it doesn't matter if you're heavily taxing the working class or forcing them into even longer commutes or artificially scarce overpriced housing when they can't afford the congestion charges. Politicians like congestion charges because they generate money instead of costing it. But it comes from the wrong people, and all you're really doing is changing the relative cost between driving and alternatives. If you want to do that, why can't you tax the rich and then make mass transit free? Or do something to lower market rate housing costs in the city so more people can live there instead of having to commute in?