3 ms·
And private software that only needs a 3-5% modification for government usage? Should that be required to open-source the entire software? Should the governme
by tracker1 8y ago
And private software that only needs a 3-5% modification for government usage? Should that be required to open-source the entire software? Should the government have to pay tens of millions and years of waiting to re-create said software?
- dragonwriter 8y ago> And private software that only needs a 3-5% modification for government usage? Should that be required to open-source the entire software? I think there is a good argument for anything where the government is acquiring software rather than paying for service that the acquired software (even if it zero percent modified) should be under a permissive open source license (or even acquired into the public domain), and the source code should be a disclosable public record except to the extent it would be covered by privacy, security, or other existing exceptions to public records laws.
- tracker1 8y agoSo, you'd rather spend millions and years of time extra than to use closed source software?
- dragonwriter 8y ago> So, you'd rather spend millions and years of time extra than to use closed source software? No, I'd rather save millions and years of time than use closed source software (if it's zero modification COTS, the extra cost comes in organizing operations around software limitations rather than business driving tools, if it's 3-5% modification at acquisition MOTS, then the additional cost is the continued modifications necessary as government needs evolve differently than private needs with the original vendor able to charge want amounts to monopoly rents because there are no substitute providers because the vendor owns the code, or you fail back to business organized around software rather than vice versa again.) I've actually spent quite a while working in public sector IT in a unit which manages COTS, MOTS, and we-own-the-code solutions. (Now there are some exceptions, just as FOIA has exceptions as to which government records are disclosable, but by far I'd prefer the baseline would be code acquired by government must belong to or be freely usable by the public, either PD or permissively-licensed.)