3 ms·
> What alternatives are there to the ubiquitous "hamburger menu" for navigation that look good on both mobile and desktop? Step one is to stop trying to make t
by wtallis 8y ago
> What alternatives are there to the ubiquitous "hamburger menu" for navigation that look good on both mobile and desktop?
Step one is to stop trying to make the same UI for mobile and desktop. You're guaranteed to end up with a result that is insultingly bad for at least one of those segments of your user base.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hombre_fatal 8y agoThe issue is that you can always show more options on desktop. On mobile, you naturally have to choose fewer menu items to display. Where do you put the rest? The worst is when the mobile version doesn't have those additional menu items at all, anywhere, and certain things are simply impossible to do on mobile. Tossing the lower priority items onto an additional page (hamburger menu) when screen space is limited is often the fair and simple trade-off. "Don't use hamburger menus" is often coupled with the hand-wavy "just create novel mobile UI that doesn't need it", but the reality is that the items in hamburger menus usually don't need their own top-level button on a small screen at all. That's why they're hidden behind a click. They aren't worth the clutter, but they're still things a user may want to do. In my experience, seeing that just about everything uses the hamburger menu, like the Kindle, it's a concession users are willing to make in order to use a small device. What exactly is the trade-off here without downsides?
- platz 8y agoI would not characterize the "hamburger menu" as an "additional page". I would call that a "flyout". An additional page means that you navigate away - so you'd then be navigating to a sub-page that displays more links, if you did it that way.
- hombre_fatal 8y agoAgreed, I phrased it that way because, for some reason, an additional page seems more agreeable to people in these discussions, yet a hamburger menu is really just a much more convenient take on that: a quick flyout that only covers part of the screen.
- contextfree 8y ago"hamburger menus are bad" vs. "no they're good" is such a silly argument to have - all you know about a UI that uses a "hamburger menu" is that there's an icon with three lines involved somewhere. You don't know what the application is for, what options are in the menu, or even the mechanics of the hamburger menu itself - for example on Windows the built-in "hamburger menu" control shows icons in compact state and can be expanded by default, which avoids most of the problems with options being buried, etc. It's frustrating that UI discussions tend to stay on such a superficial level.