6 ms·
> Should the IRS, NSA, CIA, and FBI code all be open source? Yes. Open source, but secret/classified (as necessary, IRS software should be open-source, period)
by AlexandrB 8y ago
> Should the IRS, NSA, CIA, and FBI code all be open source?
Yes. Open source, but secret/classified (as necessary, IRS software should be open-source, period). This way the software will be a useful learning/historical resource when it's declassified in the future.
- vanderZwan 8y agoAlso, electronic voting. Not that electronic voting booths will ever be a good idea, but forcing them to open source their stuff will hopefully deter people from even trying (and if not it will make it even more blatantly visible that these things are terrible). It's just like the biggest argument for open source in science: it is required for proper accountability.
- ganoushoreilly 8y agoMost of the code in electronic voting is owned by the vendors though so by the same standard would we have to open source any 3rd party software the govt aquires?
- PurpleBoxDragon 8y agoI think it would have to be a requirement of any money the government spends on code. Otherwise, they will easily defeat the requirement to make it public by passing it through a private company.
- vanderZwan 8y agoI don't quite follow your line of thinking here: - currently most electronic voting software is owned by the vendors - electronic voting should really not be trusted, period, but definitely not be allowed to be closed source - therefore, we should ban any electronic voting software not made on open source software (arguably even hardware) - therefore, I am implying vendors of electronic voting software should only be allowed to use a fully open source software stack in their final product I do not see the jump from this reasoning to any software used by the government must be open source (if I understand you correctly).
- throwawaymath 8y agoThat's a lot more involved and domain-specific than the question of whether or not government-owned code should be open source. The person you're responding to is just making the positive observation that, since electronic voting software is licensed - not produced - by the government, you can't mandate it be open sourced via e.g. a FOIA request. You are making a normative declaration that it should be open sourced because it's important and intrinsically untrusted software, and as a consequence it either will be or electronic voting won't be possible. These are separate things. You're talking about what ought to be, the other commenter is talking about what (currently) is.
- vanderZwan 8y agoRight, I see where GP and I were talking past each other now now. Thank you for clarifying!
- vanderZwan 8y agoHaving said that, I think there is a more general point to be made from bringing up electronic voting in the discussion of open source + government funded software development. Licensed products are an inevitable loophole to be exploited unless we stipulate rules for use-cases like this. Inevitable because some products will always be licensed, and mandating that everything the government uses must be open source is... well, actually, that sounds great, but even if such a policy were implemented that would be a slow, tough transition to make.
- MadWombat 8y ago> Not that electronic voting booths will ever be a good idea Why not?
- ianwalter 8y agoYes, open source IRS software. Tax breaks for bug fixes!
- Consultant32452 8y agoWhat do I get for sending in a malformed e-file that breaks the mainframe? There's some REALLY old code in the IRS processing systems and it would surprise me if any of it stood up to modern security designs. Also, you don't want to reveal how you determine who to audit.
- jsymolon 8y ago> who to audit. Doesn't have to be complicated, pull 10% of the "simple" forms, 90% of complicated. Simple forms would be the 1040EZ, 1040s w/ std deductions & no other "business" forms.
- Consultant32452 8y agoI highly doubt that the real code is random in that way. I'm sure there's some random aspect, but not all. If you're committing tax fraud, it's very valuable to know how to avoid tripping up the "audit this account" triggers.
- ianwalter 8y agoThis is assuming "who to audit" is even a software process or completely a software process, but fine, don't open source that if necessary. I really just want the IRS software that I personally use to be open source.
- rtkwe 8y agoThere are some things the IRS shouldn't release like their fraud detection or anything related to deciding who should get audited. Releasing that risks big bad actors working around the limitations of whatever algorithms it contains.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> There are some things the IRS shouldn't release like their fraud detection or anything related to deciding who should get audited That's perhaps a good reason for that part of the software to not be published and/or FOIA disclosable, but that's orthogonal to how it is licensed. If it's an original government work now it would be public domain (which is more open than open source), but still potentially confidential and nondisclosable.
- creatornator 8y agoWhile I appreciate the distinction between license and classification, does it really matter if a piece of software is "in the public domain" if its very existence and content is classified and non-disclosable? It may as well not exist as far as open-source or public domain is concerned.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> While I appreciate the distinction between license and classification, does it really matter if a piece of software is "in the public domain" if its very existence and content is classified and non-disclosable? If the entire work is, less so than if it was disclosable (although there are laws governing the government use of copyright protected work, and arguably there is a benefit to the public interest if the vendor has provided and open source license even if the work is not publicly disclosable.) But practically, classification and, perhaps even moreso, the other exceptions to FOIA would often apply to limited portions of software systems rather than whole systems, as is often the case with other materials covered by FOIA.
- 8y ago