5 ms·
Assuming a product person ( e.g Steve Jobs ) is easily Angry and Irritable with crap ( Which there are lots of it ), would that considered as depressed? Where
by ksec 8y ago
Assuming a product person ( e.g Steve Jobs ) is easily Angry and Irritable with crap ( Which there are lots of it ), would that considered as depressed? Where do we draw a line where some body just have very high standard to everything ( Perfectionist ) or they actually have bipolar disorder.
- cmiller1 8y agoThe line between personality traits and mental disorder is usually drawn at "does this have a significant negative impact on the person's functioning?"
- justtopost 8y agoIf our functioning is negative due to our environment, rather than the impetus to our actions, what then?
- mLuby 8y agoIt's unfortunate, but the environment is unlikely to change, so if you dislike your symptoms you've gotta change what you can. That said, if you can change your environment (new job, new home, new friends, etc) that's going to be a heck of a lot easier than changing yourself.
- ashleyn 8y agoI've known many people who have Jobsian tendencies. They don't have depression, just a low tolerance for bullshit.
- ergothus 8y ago> just a low tolerance for bullshit. How about "just a low tolerance for what they perceive as bullshit"? It seems many such people perceive things like manners, respect for other people, and anything that doesn't push their personal current priority as "bullshit".
- tabtab 8y agoHow you deliver unpleasant news matters. You will be shunned and bad-mouthed if you don't find amiable ways to deliver unpleasant information. The author Dale Carnegie was mostly right; I'm just the messenger. ("How to Win Friends and Influence Others.")
- QuercusMax 8y agoOr they may just be jerks...
- tabtab 8y agoA lot of creative and successful ideas come from people of borderline/questionable mental health. That may the be reason these conditions exist in the gene pool: somebody has to ruffle feathers every now and then to keep societies from becoming stale. However, the journey may not always be pleasant.
- JeremyBanks 8y agoThe problem with that kind of evolutionary argument is that it requires the product of that creativity to impart a reproductive advantage to the creator and their close relatives. However, creations are often easily copied, producing a broader benefit that negates the evolutionary advantage. It's not impossible, but it's a tricky thing to argue.
- smaddox 8y agoA more complete analysis requires taking into account that epigenetics can allow such traits to be deactivated in most individuals and that humans are an extremely social species. These details combine to make natural selection of such complex traits both possible and beneficial to the social group.
- tabtab 8y agoThat's pretty much what I was going to reply: Being beneficial to an individual and being beneficial to a particular gene are not always the same thing. Having a particular gene in a population may be a net benefit to the group (and gene) even if it could hinder a specific individual under certain gene combinations or societal conditions. As an example, an individual who likes tinkering with weapons instead of socializing may come up with a novel weapon modification. That individual may die earlier than average due to lack-luster social skills, but the improved weapon makes the tribe thrive and grow, spreading the gene that made the weapon-obsessed individual, which was probably already in the population.
- posix_compliant 8y ago> creations are often easily copied Unless they aren't. > that negates the evolutionary advantage Unless it doesn't. Not only are you speculating, but you're making blanket statements within your speculations.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pizza 8y agoIf their mood is fragile enough to be set off by sub-perfect product design, either they’re depressed, or they’re realizing they’ve mistakenly invested the best years of their life and their life savings into the wrong product, IMO.
- pdpi 8y agoIt doesn't have to be bipolar disorder, plain old depression will do this to you. Speaking from experience, the line is fairly easy to draw. I get benignly irritated at bullshit all the time, and the anger and irritation that comes with depression is, internally, _very_ different. It's not merely "this stuff is aggravating", but rather "this triggered my fight-or-flight response, and I chose fight" — and reacting like that to even small things.
- JimBrimble35 8y agoThis comment shows a fairly incomplete knowledge of the mental health spectrum. Not that I'm an expert myself, but I will weigh in with the knowledge I do have. "would that be considered depressed?" The article refers mostly to the absence of anger from the adult diagnosis of depression, and talks about how it may be valuable to include it. To be considered depressed, I would say that the individual would probably have to fit other metrics for the diagnosis for depression as well. "Where do we draw the line" We don't, really. Mental health is a complex spectrum of behaviors. Perhaps Jobs was depressed, perhaps he suffered from some un-diagnosed OCD or he had symptoms from any number of other known psychological issues. Maybe he just learned to be a dick early in life and that was part of his personality. If we pick apart peoples personalities and compare them to symptoms, we'll find a fit for everyone, but that isn't really helpful anyway.
- awfuleverything 8y agoThere's a pretty good consensus that Steve had obsessive compulsive personality disorder. It's different from OCD, and places a big emphasis on perfectionism. I believe his irritability and anger at people he worked with was due to his frustration of people not striving for perfection like he did. I was diagnosed with OCPD a couple years ago, and after knowing all my symptoms and thinking about Steve's personality, it makes a lot of sense. The thing that sealed it for me? Steve struggled with food and eating disorders throughout his life. This is a common trait of people with OCPD and people struggling with perfectionism.
- davidcbc 8y ago> Assuming a product person ( e.g Steve Jobs ) is easily Angry and Irritable with crap ( Which there are lots of it ), would that considered as depressed? Maybe, but not necessarily. Just like how being sad doesn't necessarily mean you are depressed. It is feasible Jobs could have improved his day to day life and handled his anger better by seeing a mental health professional, but it would be irresponsible to have armchair psychologists posthumously diagnose him with something.