5 ms·
> " They are willing to give up privacy for free email. " How exactly does Google/GMail violate the users' privacy with email? They process the messages, show
by pas 8y ago
> " They are willing to give up privacy for free email. "
How exactly does Google/GMail violate the users' privacy with email?
They process the messages, show hyper-targeted ads. End of story.
But is there a Cambridge Analytica for GMail? Can some "app" exfiltrate the emails? Or the contacts of users?
- blakesterz 8y agoI am so far willing to give up some small amount of privacy for free email, though I'd also pay Google for it because it is simply the best email hosting I could find. I don't want to host my own email, hosting email sucks. I've tried other email hosters and they just weren't as good. They also have security in place that takes care of all the big things in my threat model. So when it comes to email... yeah, it's not as private as it could be, but it's about the best I can find for everything else. It ain't perfect, but it's the best option for me right now. Maybe it won't be in a year or two?
- epistasis 8y agoWhat you describe sounds exactly like giving up privacy to me, even if it doesn't sound like giving up privacy to you. And then when you add in all the other tracking that Google does of your web history, search history, location data, that is pretty much all your privacy gone. Let's say I pay an assistant to help with my email. Even though they are in my employ, I'm still giving up my privacy for the service. Google gives us email service in exchange for that peek in to our private lives.
- fixermark 8y ago"An assistant to help with my X" is a pretty solid, concise description of Google's service suite, complete with the observation about privacy.
- savanaly 8y agoOk so then you need to invent a new word for what is lost when companies further cross the line from [using your data in a totally internal and in fact internal to just your account]. Because it seems like a big step from treating your data as a tool to affect your experience to selling it to other companies to do whatever they want with. What is the primary word associated with that step if not "privacy"?
- mehrdadn 8y agoI never understood how scanning emails to show ads is a privacy violation? No information about you is leaking to anyone.
- prophesi 8y agoI think it's the whole _scanning emails_. The information is already leaked at that point.
- mehrdadn 8y agoLeaked to whom though? That's what I don't get. No human is involved in the process and your information is in the hands of the same company as before.
- prophesi 8y agoThat's a lot of trust in a black box coded by humans. What's going on under the hood with their Smart Compose? Smart Reply? Smart Labels? It all requires processing very very personal information, and you simply can't vet whether it's all handled securely.
- mehrdadn 8y agoSure, you're trusting their code is bug free. That's just (lack of) faith on your end. The fact that you decide not to trust their competence certainly does not logically imply that they are invading your privacy. It just means you need to trust their competence or take your business to some company you deem more competent. (Though exactly which company would be more competent in infosec is quite the question, but I digress.)
- prophesi 8y agoNo, it's a lot more than just trusting that their code is bug-free. It's trusting that they're actually only doing what they claim to be doing with your data. The only solution is to have the code open sourced with reproducible builds and a checksum to verify it against. Pretty much every GApp has a free, libre, open-source alternative that respects your privacy in this way.
- valker43 8y agoIn essence, yes. Except the human assistant could technically be coerced to spill the beans on you. Via bribes or blackmail, etc. Gmail dosen't. The ads you see have nothing to do with your mail activity. They haven't for a while now. Not saying Google is a paragon of privacy, mind you. https://support.google.com/mail/answer/6603?hl=en https://support.google.com/mail/answer/6603?hl=en
- dmitrygr 8y agoThat hasn't been the case for nearly five years... Gmail messages are NOT used for any ad targeting.
- JBerlinsky 8y agoYes, developers can request permission to access your inbox "offline" (i.e. at any time, with a long-term access token). The scope is clearly identified in the OAuth authentication process, and the consent screen clearly asks for permission to (IIRC) "read, write, and delete emails." There are a few well-known applications (Earny and Unroll.me come to mind, off the top of my head) that are known to work with consumer research operations with the resulting data.
- bassman9000 8y agoThey process the messages That's SVspeak for they read your emails Yes, yes. I know it's a machine.
- pas 8y agoAny email host reads you emails. And not everyone is up to the task of hosting their own emails.