3 ms·
I really hope this leads to a reform in the whole EULA thing. I've always really disliked that they have a fifty page document outlining all the minutia in a le
by tombert 8y ago
I really hope this leads to a reform in the whole EULA thing. I've always really disliked that they have a fifty page document outlining all the minutia in a legal language that I personally don't know a lot about.
You could argue that I should thoroughly read everything, and that's fair enough for stuff I do at home, but very often I have to install things for work, and if I say that I need to spend four hours consulting with the legal team to install Microsoft Office, I honestly feel that they'll think I'm just trying to waste time.
- rjf72 8y agoWhile I completely agree, I think there's a more fundamental problem. Imagine Facebook's T&C said, "We will spy on you in any and all ways we can imagine. We will take every piece of information we can possibly collect about you and use it however we want. You have no rights and if you ever sue us, you agree that we win by default. We have the right to add whatever we want to this agreement, whenever we want with immediate effect." How many people would read it, and decide not to install their software or use their site? For sure some might, but for the most part I think people would mostly just shrug and click next. Many people don't seem to understand the value of things unless it hits them directly in the wallet.
- slededit 8y agoThe “we win by default” phrase is also in some scummier payday loan contracts and is apparently legal. But I don’t think it should be legal to waive your court rights like that.
- tombert 8y agoI remember during the Equifax breach of 2017, they put that clause in there if you signed up for their credit monitoring system. I always thought those clauses were funny...would that hold up anywhere else? "Hey, sorry I shot you...here's a bandaid, now you can't sue me!"
- tzs 8y agoMaking EULAs easier to deal with could be part of privacy legislation or tied to such legislation. The things covered by privacy legislation will generally fall into three groups. 1. Things that you cannot agree to forego or allow, 2. Things that you can agree to forego or allow, but only as part of an actual negotiation, not implicitly by saying you agree to a EULA, and 3. Things that you can agree to forego or allow by indicating agreement to a EULA, such as by clicking an "I agree" link on a EULA screen. The privacy legislation could say that in order to get such agreement a EULA must list in a separate section all the items it has from #3, explicitly citing the section and name for each item from the privacy law. The idea behind the explicit cite to the privacy law is to provide a standard term for each item, so you won't get confused by different companies having different names for the same thing. This wouldn't cover all the things one might find in a EULA, such as liability limitations, choice of law or choice of venue clauses, arbitration clauses, etc., but it would make it a lot easier to quickly check to see what privacy rights you might be giving up if you click through.