4 ms·
The title and the content are different. As I read through > Le Parisien cite l'exemple d'un employé qui aurait donné rendez-vous à des collègues "devant la p
by csomar 8y ago
The title and the content are different. As I read through
> Le Parisien cite l'exemple d'un employé qui aurait donné rendez-vous à des collègues "devant la porte de son lieu de travail pour partir bloquer un entrepôt voisin, à Lesquin", dans le Nord. Un autre aurait lancé : "Il faut du renfort et des palettes, les amis !"
Basically the guy organized with his co-workers to blockade a warehouse (I assume of Amazon).
I don't think they fired guys that vocally supported Yellow Vests demands. Those would be in the hundreds if not thousands. It seems to me like they fired trouble makers.
I have only a couple words: Good riddance. Saying this as someone who has been affected by blockades (in another country) and seen people, companies and business being affected and devastated by it.
There is a difference between complaining and blocking a road/access.
- mschuster91 8y ago> There is a difference between complaining and blocking a road/access. Yes, complaining does nothing (most if not all complaints die out in the political machinery), while blocking roads etc. usually tends to yield immediate results once those with power in society are affected themselves. Macron was forced to make a lot of concessions towards the poorer population. If you want to make a political statement as ordinary citizen these days you need to do something with real measurable impact. While I don't think throwing molotovs on McDonald's is a viable path to solutions, grinding the infrastructure to a halt by mass protests/strikes certainly is.
- csomar 8y agoSounds good until everyone starts doing it and the whole country collapses. Cool isn't it? There is a reason why there are democratic institutions. The correct way to do it, is to wait for the next election and elect your preferred president. You can also strike on your current job (at your own risk), leave your government job, leave the country. Blocking a public road does not help anyone and makes you more of a pirate.
- mschuster91 8y ago> Sounds good until everyone starts doing it and the whole country collapses. Well, better than having a situation like in Germany where the "Agenda 2010" reforms created an entire class of people working full-time but effectively being poor, called "Arbeitsprekariat". French protests have so far succeeded to prevent the repeating of German mistakes. > The correct way to do it, is to wait for the next election and elect your preferred president. The problem in France was that they had two choices thanks to kick-out voting: either far-right Le Pen or neoliberal Macron. So many chose Macron, simply to prevent Le Pen from winning. To say that Macron is the legitimate president wanted by the majority of French population is... a stretch.
- entity345 8y agoMacron is not "neoliberal"... France needs reforms and has been postponing them for decades. What Macron is trying to do is needed and long overdue.
- brmgb 8y ago> France needs reforms and has been postponing them for decades. France needs stability a lot more than reforms. As a country, France still has a highly educated population, great infrastructure, a rich internal market and a solid canvas of small, medium and large business. France should be seeking growth through innovation and investment rather than constantly tweaking its tax code. France is however deeply handicaped by the euro. It is in my opinion the first victim of German dumping (the Hartz reform). The whole France needs reform mantra is more rooted in ideology than facts. Macron is a Blairite who would rather fight the German by similarly depressing wages rather than confront them directly. It is a losing situation for everyone except the employers and will only lead to more inequality and more poverty in Europe. But well, guess who financed Macron presidential campain...
- entity345 8y agoHow do you achieve growth? That's the key issue. That's why the country needs reforms. Because the chronic lack of growth leads to protests like the Yellow Vests's. It is not handicaped by the Euro. The issue is systemic: Red tape, anti-business, anti-innovation, bloated public sector.
- close04 8y ago> Yes, complaining does nothing (most if not all complaints die out in the political machinery), while blocking roads etc. usually tends to yield immediate results Now imagine a neighbor being disturbed by your noisy party but instead of asking you to turn it down or calling the Police, he welds your doors and windows shut and cuts your electricity. Now you tell me if the practical application of your own suggestion sounds reasonable.
- gamblor956 8y agoTo make your hypothetical match the facts of this situation, imagine that your neighbors had been doing that for months on end, ignored your requests to keep the volume down, and the police never did anything about it despite your repeated complaints. In such case, your response would not have been entirely unreasonable.
- close04 8y agoBut once you do it do you have a moral or legal claim on anything anymore? If the same neighbor beats you silly for ruining his party can you then go to the Police or court and ask them for help and justice? Can you say "but he was doing the same or worse"? Can you claim innocence because you unilaterally decided that you are in charge of settling the matter? How exactly do you decide what is the appropriate response? These are honest questions, I'm genuinely curious how people here see it. Even if I can assume internet opinions are very different from real life ones. You are always free to take any action you deem appropriate but you will also have to take the consequences. So you can block your employer's warehouse in protest for something but then why be surprised when the time comes to pay for it?
- gamblor956 8y agoI don't understand your argument. The fact that you and/or your neighbor committed crimes against each other doesn't negate the crimes you have committed. You're both guilty and the police would likely arrest both of you. That being said, whether your response in the original hypothetical is reasonable is not the same thing as whether it is legal or moral. In all 3 hypothetical actions, the act is illegal. In some cases, a lesser illegal act is justified to prevent a greater legal act but the specifics of that depends on the jurisdiction. So you can block your employer's warehouse in protest for something but then why be surprised when the time comes to pay for it? In this case, both Amazon and the employees have violated the law. The law the employees violated was a lesser law than the numerous laws Amazon violated. Amazon is very likely to face a lawsuit in court and lose--the French are extremely protective of labor rights.