4 ms·
Does anyone know how this act would interact with the first amendment? It's my understanding that the first amendment is extremely broad - if donating money ca
by michaelt 8y ago
Does anyone know how this act would interact with the first amendment?
It's my understanding that the first amendment is extremely broad - if donating money can be counted as protected speech, surely 'parody' videos of politicians would also be?
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoWell making a deep fake is legal, however using it for illegal activities is not - freedom of speech is not freedom of consequences. You're free to make a bomb threat and nobody will silence you if you do, but it's likely the FBI will knock on your door. It's not about what you say (or in this case produce), it's about your intent.
- dTal 8y agoNot to disagree with your statement about intent, but... >freedom of speech is not freedom of consequences ...that's not a very convincing form of free speech. What exactly does "free speech" mean then, if not freedom from consequences? It's not as if it's even possible to silence someone before the fact. "You are free to criticise comrade Stalin! You are also free to go to gulag!"
- paulgb 8y ago>freedom of speech is not freedom of consequences Usually when I see that statement it’s to make the point that freedom of speech (in the first amendment sense) protects you from government consequences, but not societal consequences. The government won’t stop you from saying something offensive, but your country club can kick you out for saying it. I agree with you that this sense doesn’t really apply here, though.
- zaarn 8y agoMerriam-Webster defines freedom of speech as "the legal right to express one's opinions freely". Creating a deep fake of a celebrity hardly counts as expressing your opinions and if you use it for illegal activities that's far out of scope.
- nybble41 8y ago> Creating a deep fake of a celebrity hardly counts as expressing your opinions... On its own, sure. It may still be one step in the process, however. On their own merits, renting out an audience hall or TV broadcast slot, or operating a 3D graphics program, are not "expressing one's opinions" either. These things are only a means to an end. However, restrictions on such activity would still impact your ability to effectively communicate your opinions to the public. Use of "deep fakes" (or shallow ones) in a commercial context to trick someone into purchasing goods or services or otherwise agree to a contract under false pretenses is fraud—which in the end is just a form of theft, and deserves to be treated as such. That doesn't violate the 1st Amendment because it's not the speech per se which is being punished, but rather the act of taking someone else's stuff when its ownership was never properly transferred to you through a valid contract. Contracts require "meeting of the minds", which is precluded by fraud. Other than that narrow scope, the law has no business being involved.
- zaarn 8y ago>Other than that narrow scope, the law has no business being involved. I would disagree there. The personal rights of the people who are being deepfaked (both provider of body acting and the face) are violated unless you get consent from both. These personal rights in my opinion also trump any free speech rights as these people have their own, more important rights to their body and images thereof.
- nybble41 8y agoThe most stringent proportional response available to punish people for creating these "deep fakes" would simply be for those offended by the practice to do the same in return. That is their right, of course—turnabout is always fair play—and it may help reduce the impact of the original fake video, but it's unlikely to be seen as much of a punishment. > as these people have their own, more important rights to their body and images thereof Nonsense. You do own your physical body, of course, and consequently have the right to use it as you please, but there is no right to control images of your body. That would be tantamount to claiming the right to control the contents of others' minds. Note that your right to use your body does not imply that you have the right to use others' bodies or other property as you please just because your own body happens to be involved. Owners have the right to veto any action which affects their use of their property; in other words, you have the right to do whatever you want as long as it involves only your own property, but need others' consent if your actions would impact their use of their property. Regarding the image: (a) the image (the content, as opposed to the physical media) is not property; (b) even if it were, it would not be your property; (c) even if it were your property, someone else's use of the image would not have any impact on your own ability to use it, so you wouldn't have the right to veto that use. Rights sometimes overlap, but they never conflict and are certainly never "trumped" by other rights.
- SamuelAdams 8y agoPage 4, line 8: (2) FIRST AMENDMENT PROTECTION.—No person shall be held liable under this section for any activity protected by the First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States.’’.
- giornogiovanna 8y agoBut what activity does this act prohibit, that isn't "protected by the First Amendment"?
- fiblye 8y agoLibel is a crime and some states have defamation laws. It wouldn't be hard to tack this onto those and--if they really want to push it, which they will if given the chance--make it a sex crime to get that lifelong punishment.
- jdpedrie 8y agoThis seems like a bit of CYA on the part of the drafters for the inevitable court challenge. "We did consider the constitutional issues, we promise!" Without specifics, that line is meaningless. edit: This speaks to a larger problem with how our representatives work these days. They're supposed to respect the limits placed on their power and they're supposed to guard the powers they are given jealously. Instead, they trip over each other to run away from their lawful authority, and when they finally decide to "do something", limits are dismissed with a wave of the hand.
- 3pt14159 8y agoParody is a valid defence only if a reasonable person would consider it as parody. We have libel laws. They work well enough. I think of this an extension of libel protection. Though in the long run, the defence will need to be algorithmic. Not all actors are stateside.