5 ms·
Could someone more familiar with the subject and vernacular provide some sort of summary of what this is trying to say? I've read it two or three times and I s
by ColinWright 8y ago
Could someone more familiar with the subject and vernacular provide some sort of summary of what this is trying to say? I've read it two or three times and I still can't work out the point being made.
If any.
- npo_ 8y agoMaybe I'm just ignorant, but this article reads like one of those corporate jargon text generators to me.
- drngdds 8y agoI'm pretty lost too. It reads like the second half of an article with no context.
- coupdejarnac 8y agoSometimes I worry that I present my thoughts as incoherently as the author. This article needs to be streamlined and stripped of the confusing snark halfway though.
- theoh 8y ago"Tasks which require thought are exhausting and qualitatively different from routine tasks. Is there a better way to coordinate the work environment of "knowledge workers" to make their lives easier?"
- acemarke 8y agoWhat I'm getting out of it is that idealized notions of "knowledge sharing" and "task management" are unrealistic compared to how people actually work on things in the real world, and that software meant to help people work on long-running tasks should take that into consideration. As a concrete example: I frequently find myself needing to figure out how to implement some software task I've never done before myself, involving concepts that I barely know anything about. This usually results in dozens of opened tabs in multiple subtrees - Google searches, Github repos, and so on. This might overflow my main "browsing" Firefox window, so I end up opening a second FF window just to hold those tabs. Per the article, maybe there's a better way to capture the notion of "I'm trying to research this topic over the course of a week - how do I better organize what I'm working on, and perhaps share that info with others?".
- regrub 8y agoYour concrete example is the main reason I've switched from Firefox to Vivaldi. You can create either "tab stacks", which group multiple tabs into a single top-level tab, and which can even be unloaded all at once. If you want a more persistent (and I think even shareable) version, you can then save the group as a session.
- harryf 8y agoSo to me it made some sense. Putting it in my own terms, he argues knowledge workers are _by default_ overloaded and they use distractions as a necessary form of relief from the pressure - the distractions aren't the problem, they're a symptom. Right now we're too focused on tools and strategies to make us "more efficient", block distractions and promote collaboration. Instead we should focus on reducing the mental drain of knowledge work (e.g. the need for endless multi-tasking and alt-tabbing), find ways for positive mental relaxation (here I guess implied is NOT drugs or alcohol) and support getting "back on track" e.g. if you finish the day half way through fixing a bug, when you start next day, it's not just your IDE but also say your browser with all the Stack Overflow tabs and such you had open, related to the bug, all together in a "session" that makes it as easy as possible to pick up where you left off. So in summary I guess he's saying in the search for solutions to burnt out knowledge workers we're focused too much on symptoms like distractions.
- philipodonnell 8y agoCan chrome or Firefox do an "exit but save all my tabs"? I find myself force closing Chrome because I can use the recover tabs when I come back.
- cortesoft 8y agoYou can do "restore previous session" from the hamburger menu the next time you start up, even if you don't force close.
- kbenson 8y agoIf you close Chrome normally and on reopening attempt to undo closing a tab (Ctrl-Shift-t on Windows) it will reopen all the closed, and even separate windows with their own tabs (maybe that takes a second Ctrl-Alt-t, I can't recall). Firefox just opens with all the same tabs by default (at least it does for me. I don't recall if it's a setting I selected).
- goodcanadian 8y agoFirefox just opens with all the same tabs by default (at least it does for me. I don't recall if it's a setting I selected). It's a setting. In your preferences, under start-up, check restore previous session. IIRC, you can also restore the previous session from the history menu even if you don't have that option checked.
- modarts 8y agoSame reaction, there’s a point buried extremely deep in all of the stream of consciousness
- whatshisface 8y agoThe article is a stream-of-consciousness about distractions and multitasking. The author does not reach a conclusion, instead hoping only to inspire further thought.
- svat 8y agoWhen people discuss “knowledge work”, they often slip into imagining an “idealized” knowledge worker: one who is very engaged, and doing “big” meaningful things one at a time. In reality, (1) we are all distracted, (2) our work usually consists of a large number of small chunks that are spread over time (3) we all have a large pile of undone work (both “job” and “personal”) that we're always feeling guilty about. What do we do about this difference between the ideal and reality? We could just give up on the ideal and resign to the reality — or even make it worse. Or we could try to fight it superficially, and fail (there's a reason things are the way they are). Or we could start from accepting the reality (instead of ignoring it), but try to move towards the ideal, e.g: (1) reduce whatever it is that makes us seek distractions (very different from blocking distractions), (2) make it easier to get back on track (e.g. keep track of the task being done). In coming up with this problem statement, the author believes he's diverged from the usual problems being imagined: things like trying to block distractions, trying to maximize efficiency, “collaboration”. [That just restated the post, so I don't know if it helps :)]
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoA brilliant précis that is actually better than the original article (sorry Mr Bicking)
- TuringTest 8y agoI have an idea for your (2), which is a tool for interrupting you when you are procrastinating, and showing something interesting to do from your TO DO list, adequate to the current moment and place. This could use all the addictiveness techniques of current "engagement+advertising" platforms and turn it to good use.
- commandlinefan 8y ago> who is very engaged, and doing “big” meaningful things one at a time. And one who knows exactly what steps are going to be involved and how long each one is going to take, weeks or even months in advance. The fact that I approach every new programming problem with: "ok, how the hell do I figure this one out?" made me feel really nervous early on in my career, since there seemed to be this default expectation that not just good, not even just adequate, but even mediocre programmers could blurt out a list of the tasks involved in solving a problem, "estimate" (meaning predict with +/- 5% accuracy) the hours associated with each and then robotically plow through each of them. This was back in the 90's, before somebody named this "agile" and built a set of Orwellian tools and "coaching strategies" around it, but after a few years I couldn't help but notice that, in spite of being an abject failure at accurately predicting how long each bug fix was going to take before I even really knew what it entailed, I was also one of the most sought after developers in every organization I worked at.