8 ms·
>It's entirely reasonable to show a challenge after a couple of failed login attempts, but they should never be part of the default login flow. Nope, that only
by hombre_fatal 8y ago
>It's entirely reasonable to show a challenge after a couple of failed login attempts, but they should never be part of the default login flow.
Nope, that only works if there weren't botnets that just multiplex millions of requests over thousands of websites.
Anyone who has tried IP-blocking bots has run into this where 50k+ IP addresses just need to send you one request per couple minutes.
Your posts in this thread show how easy it is to be against recaptcha without addressing why people use it, or you suggest it's a flawed security model when people use it. It's kind of hard to take your advice seriously when I think of real world websites fighting real world abuse.
In another post of yours, you recommend the web developer to just expend more and more effort to circumvent abuse without recaptcha. Like creating a whole pending message system for, say, a forum instead of just a contact form. In fact, you'll find that there's no shortage of work for you to do once you attract abuse. And that's an easy solution to prescribe when you have no skin in the game. God forbid the site doesn't even make any money.
- darkpuma 8y agoreCAPTCHA's tile fade-in doesn't punish bots, it punishes real humans. Your argument might be valid if reCAPTCHA were a true CAPTCHA, rather than compliance/recruiting mechanism used by google to abuse people until they relent and adopt google products. But yeah, it's free so you can't resist using it. Have you ever stopped to wonder why google gives this service out for free? When you integrate reCAPTCHA into your website, you're selling your users out.
- hombre_fatal 8y agoWell, it's something that works. HN uses it, too. Try to create an account over Tor. It sucks that abuse exists, but it's a real problem and it's only getting easier to do and harder to avoid. After all, what also bones users is having a platform that's trivial to attack because the developer thought abuse wasn't going to be a problem.
- PSZD 8y agoHumans are the problem, not some mythical AI powering the bots. It costs a fraction of a cent to get a CAPTCHA solved. The only real counter being used is making it take longer to solve a CAPTCHA - which is exactly what the services like reCAPTCHA do, while minimizing the impact on heuristically 'good' users. Making CAPTCHA solves take 30 seconds or a minute instead of 5 seconds is the state of the art.
- darkpuma 8y agoThe heuristic google uses for 'good' is 'compliance with the google surveillance system.' And if throttling attempts is in fact the state of the art as you claim, you can do that without pulling in google code at all. I trust you are that competent at least. However the fact that the noscript version doesn't make you wait at all leads me to conclude your excuse for google's behavior is bullshit.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dessant 8y agoI would have appreciated if your post would not have been a personal attack. I was suggesting limiting login attempts based on a particular user account, not an IP address, and I have never talked about a pending message system for forums.
- rabidrat 8y ago> limiting login attempts based on a particular user account, not an IP address. How do you do this on account creation?
- dessant 8y agoAccount creation is different from a login attempt.
- hombre_fatal 8y agoMost brute-forcing at scale isn't for a specific account, it's for {uname,password} tuples. As in, you buy these combo lists online and rent a botnet to try them out on a list of sites. What would your advice achieve? I changed the "you" to "your advice", but I think that's a petty distraction since I'm making specific points against your advice, not you as a person. And this comment is an example of what seems to be a disconnect between your understood attack models and the attacks that people actually need to defend against.
- dessant 8y agoDiscord defends against combo lists by showing a CAPTCHA and asking for email confirmation if you log in from a new location, but no challenge is shown during the default login flow.