5 ms·
The argument against here that I find most compelling is that the externalities of you driving your car are so insanely huge that it should be priced into the r
by gpm 8y ago
The argument against here that I find most compelling is that the externalities of you driving your car are so insanely huge that it should be priced into the range of ridiculousness.
Things that you have to consider (The numbers attached are completely made up and probably off by multiple orders of magnitude in most cases, but are to make the point that you should be assigning costs to these things. Then you should multiply by them by reasonable estimates of the quantities that make up the denominator on the unit and see what you come up with. Also note that as there are less cars on the road the externalities per car probably go up):
- Air quality (say, 0.1c per person you drive past?)
- Noise polution (say, 0.1c per person you drive past?)
- Road size - realestate cost (say, 0.000001c/trip per per person who pays taxes?)
- Road size - increased walking (and other travel) time (say, 0.0000001c/trip per person who crosses a road you drove on?)
- Congestion (say, 1c for everyone on a bus behind you?)
- Road maintenance (probably negligible compared to the other costs)
- Pedestrian safety (...)
- Climate change (...)
Our society exists not just because we're willing to be slightly inconvenienced by our neighbors, but because we are willing to go to reasonable lengths to avoid inconveniencing our neighbors. Perhaps, reasonable lengths includes not driving into the city.
- briandear 8y agoWhen every subway stop has elevators, then we cannot talk. Until then, try transporting kids or groceries using the subway. When the sidewalks are cleared of construction scaffolding, bike share racks blocking sidewalks or crazy grown adults dressing like Spider-Man, or psychotic homeless harassing people, then maybe we can talk. As far as climate change; if NYC went to zero CO2, it wouldn’t make a single bit of difference compared to a single day’s worth of pollution compared to a small Chinese or Indian city. Perhaps a tariff on all goods and services from China or India would be more effective than banning cars in NYC. Banning cars from NYC would have a cosmetic effect on climate change and nothing more. And, in case you weren’t aware, cars already pay huge costs in NYC. It costs over $10 just to cross a bridge or tunnel into NYC. They don’t pay a toll to leave NYC: so someone is getting money just for a car to enter the city.
- gpm 8y ago> try transporting kids or groceries using the subway Err. I was transported plenty as a kid on the subway without using elevators, so were many other kids. Groceries... generally you just walk. I live in a less dense city and it's never been a problem walking to the grocery store. Including for my parents when I was a kid. > sidewalks are cleared of... I mean, getting rid of cars means more room for sidewalks mean they are defacto cleared of this stuff. The reason it's a problem right now is they are packed into the same 5 feet as the pedestrians. > As far as climate change; if NYC went to zero CO2... I suspect you are right. I put what I consider the least compelling reasons at the bottom. > cars already pay huge costs in NYC. It costs over $10 $10 really isn't that much money... as demonstrated by the number of people who pay it. Understand that when I say the right number might be "ridiculous" I do mean "ridiculous". I'm avoiding saying specific numbers because then I have to justify them, but think thousands, possibly large numbers of thousands.
- smileysteve 8y ago> Until then, try transporting kids or groceries using the subway. I live in Atlanta, a place the NYTimes often writes about our lack of income mobility because of a lack of mobility[1]. I also live 2 blocks from the southernmost transit (midtown) connected grocery store that gets a lot of business from the poorer south side of the city. So, when you say "try transporting kids or groceries on the subway" I (and transitively, the nytimes) ask, which kids? because it's not the 20% of Atlantans that are low income and that have kids and multiple hourly wage jobs that can readily afford the costs of a car -- and they're already doing it, in a city more sprawled than NYC and other cities. [1]https://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/22/business/in-climbing-income-ladder-location-matters.html https://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/22/business/in-climbing-inco...
- Johnny555 8y agotry transporting kids or groceries using the subway. When I lived in an area where I could commute by subway, I had a full service grocery store and several smaller specialty markets (a produce market, a butcher and a bakery) on my way home (well I had to get out one stop early to pass the butcher). I see plenty of parents with kids on the subway -- though none of them have the full-size strollers you see coming out of the backs of SUVs. So instead of making one large shopping trip every week or two, I'd stop several times a week on my way home. Though now I just buy groceries online and have them delivered, in the rare cases where I do want to go to the supermarket, I take my bike.
- chroma 8y agoIt's circular logic to assume the externalities are ridiculous, therefore we must price cars into the realm of ridiculousness. If you want your argument to be more than cheering against cars, you should actually calculate the externalities and you should do so for competing modes of transportation. Heck if you're talking about noise pollution, someone dribbling a basketball is far more distracting to me than the white noise of cars. Also note that you are only calculating the costs of cars to others, not the benefits. Cars allow workers to spend less time commuting and be more productive at work, which benefits strangers. They allow people to travel farther to make purchases. They encourage the purchase of larger objects that can't be carried by hand for long distances. Their gas taxes help pay for the roads that people walk and ride bicycles on. Their tolls pay for the maintenance of bridges that bicycles and trains travel on. I'm a fan of congestion pricing, but the purpose of congestion pricing is to reduce congestion, not to be a sin tax on driving. If people time shift their driving, that's fine.
- gpm 8y ago> It's circular logic to assume the externalities are ridiculous, therefore we must price cars into the realm of ridiculousness. You're missunderstanding me, I'm just stating the possible conclusion that makes this an interesting argument (that it's ridiculously high and no one would pay it except on rare occasion) before the logic (look at all these externalities). > you should actually calculate the externalities That sounds like inviting lots of nitpicking debate on the internet. I invite you to though. If you do so in good faith and come up with a number that is reasonably low, well congrats, you shouldn't find the argument convincing. > you should do so for competing modes of transportation. True - I haven't personally because I think it's intuitive that they are far lower, if you disagree feel free to include them in your version of the calculation. > you are only calculating the costs of cars to others, not the benefits. I struggle to think of any positive externalities for personal cars. Everything you list are benefits to the owner except tolls. Tolls naturally don't count because that's the mechanism by which we ask them to pay for their externalities, to count them as a positive would be double counting. If you think there are some compelling ones, again, feel free to include them in your version of the calculation. > a sin tax on driving Pricing in externalities is not a "sin tax". A sin tax would be "being lazy (driving) is a sin so we're going to tax them for driving".
- isoskeles 8y ago> Noise pollution. How about we start taxing loud talkers? > Pedestrian safety. Congestion. And people who take up the whole sidewalk. I don’t see people arguing for extreme measures, to the point of “ridiculousness”, to improve the state of walking around cities. So I don’t take this too seriously, it doesn’t seem to be done in good faith so much as, “I don’t like cars and there are some negative externalities, let’s use this as an excuse to really screw over anyone who thinks to use one.” And of course, this is how a coastal elite most likely feels meanwhile they think traveling by airplane is okay or should even be celebrated. It’s not in good faith.
- mjmahone17 8y agoLots of people advocate for “superblocks” in lower Manhattan, where thru-traffic would be entirely banned and otherwise traffic slowed to something like 5-10mph. That is drastic, but very much in line with improving the state of walking around. Admittedly a big focus on reducing cars in major cities likely is coming from the fact that the wealthy started moving to major cities rather than commuting from suburbia. Other people car commuting really does hurt their quality of life. But that seems more an argument that we should bring these policies even to poorer dense urban areas rather than limiting their roll-out only to Manhattan and other wealthy enclaves.
- pseudonom- 8y agoThere are serious attempts to estimate the externalities that arise from automobile use in general: http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.661.7936&rep=rep1&type=pdf http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.661... Adjusting those estimates (only) for inflation, they work out to about $2.14 per gallon in driving externalities.
- gpm 8y agoNote that these estimates are attempts in general, not in the context of Manhattan, or downtown in any other city. I'm not aware of any studies that attempted to estimate them in such an environment, I think that local factors (basically density of people) change the calculation substantially.
- gambiting 8y agoSo.....even if you add it to the price of US fuel, it's still cheaper than fuel in the UK? And British cities have just as much trouble with congestion as American cities do. I guess what I mean is that if this extra money is meant to be a deterrent to driving it's just not enough. I'm not sure what the price would need to be to be honest. I've been to Portugal recently and the price of petrol is just insane - in the order of $8-9/US gallon. And yet people sitll drive, larger cities still have loads of congestion. And Portugal is very poor by European standards.
- jiban123 8y agohttps://eurogender.eige.europa.eu/events/liii-tvnfl-super-bowl-2019-new-england-patriots-vs-los-angeles-rams-live-stream https://eurogender.eige.europa.eu/events/liii-tvnfl-super-bo...
- electric_muse 8y agoIf this is a reasonable calculation, then I don’t think the costs are so insanely high.
- mnutt 8y agoWhile it looks like a reasonable attempt, it’s only looking at directly related effects. For instance, it notes that pedestrian fatalities have decreased since 1960 due to, among other things, discouraging people from walking. The effect of cars on population health would be much harder to quantify but might end up dwarfing many of the other factors.